While it's true that JD utilizes gilded hardware, it is not inherently indicative of inferior quality. Many reputable brands employ various finishes on their hardware, each with its own unique characteristics and aesthetic appeal. The patina that may develop over time could be celebrated as part of the bag's journey, adding character and charm. But I, too, have voiced my curiosity over the longevity of the hardware. I think it's something that we will just have to wait to see. However, given that things like gilded brass buttons and various gilded brass antiques are out there that are over 100 years old and still looking fabulous, I'm really not too worried about it.
Contrary to popular belief, Hermes, revered as it is, also employs machine stitching in its manufacturing process - even in their
Birkins and kelly's. It is not the method of stitching alone that determines quality, but rather the precision and craftsmanship applied.
"Lots of defects" is no fact, unless you have numbers showing that x% of all their bags have defects, or you have bought many JD bags of your own and have found all of them with terrible issues? A defect here or there will happen at any brand, even established ones. As for your concerns about apprenticeships and in-house training, it's worth noting that JD's approach may differ from Hermes', yet it does not diminish the skill and dedication of its artisans. Quality craftsmanship is not solely determined by the length of one's tenure but by the passion and expertise invested in each creation.
What initially drew me into the brand was the design and the leather. Knowing that they source leather from the Haas Tanneries and Tannery Gal was a big plus for me. I wanted semi-veg and veg leathers. I can customize the bag with different high quality leathers. I like the overall design. I like how it's constructed. The CS is wonderful.
Let's not hastily dismiss JD based on preconceived notions. Let us instead embrace the journey of this emerging brand, acknowledging its potential for growth and evolution.