Ms. March '95 navy Madison Carlyle arrived today!
Of course, in less pristine condition than expected. It was listed as new without tags, which is always a crap shoot on eBay. The turnlock and strap buckle show significant use (scratches, as opposed to just tarnish, which would be normal), color loss on the edges in a couple of spots, and 3 small scratches on the front that went through the shine, but not the color. The hang tag must have really upset someone to get beaten so badly. Leather Therapy helped make the scratches on the front less obvious. But navy seems to be hard to find, so I'm leaning towards just dealing with it, as I do want it, and partial refunds are the way of the scammer.