I have yet to purchase my first bag and have been doing extensive research. To add to this discussion, I have seen an imitation/fake CHANEL bag have a stamp/hallmark on one of the top left corners as well. I also went to the boutique at Central, Hong Kong yesterday and it did NOT have the markings on it. I guess I'm still awaiting for an answer to this as well.
Hi. M1ss
Good sleuthing. You have raised some interesting points so I'm splitting my response into two parts.
Fake bag. The one that you thought was a fake, what did it look like? Did it look like any of the photographs here? If it was an R, it was definitely fake. If it is an auction link, then you could post it to the authenticate this Chanel site. I would definitely recommend using it to any buyer.
Also, who told you it was a fake? For reference, Sales Assistants SAs are not allowed to give opinions on authenticity of items. It is not their job and they can make mistakes. Which, is
exactly why the the policy is in place.
Chanel has produced thousands and thousands of models. Often, people post items to the authenticate this Chanel link speculating that an item is fake because it looks funny to them in some way. Usually, it turns out to be OK. But sometimes the poster catches a fake, which can then be reported and protect other buyers. The authenticate this Chanel team are amazing and very experienced. If you look at how many posts they have made, you can see that they have seen a lot of Chanels.
I also collect look books of designer products. In the last 30 years alone, Chanel has produced a mind blowing array of items. Most of them I have only seen in pictures. Some SAs might be very well informed about historic ranges, but others will only have seen the ranges made since they started working. They are also employed to sell new bags. The only way Chanel really authenticate is to accept and repair your bag. If they don't repair it, that means they are concerned about authenticity. The only exception to this rule is that they also will not modify the original integrity of the bag - eg, dramatically change a color, or in some cases, do intensive cleaning on very old bags due to the risk to the leather.
New bags with no hallmark. Some of the current models no longer have the hallmark. I don't buy these so I don't know when that started. Someone else can help you on that.