Good question! Well, is it a style on your HG list? I am guessing the color is not an HG find. Do you really want a huge bag? From what I recall you already have an amazing collection. I agree that $65 seems pricey for the color and condition. However, if it was made in NYC and you are fine with allowing the space for a collection bag, and you have a desire to simply collect that style/ vintage then go for it. I have decided to look for small bags, that are not too pricey (which can vary with the bag), either made in NYC or harder to find style/color for collecting.
Funny you mention this, I found a black Duffle at thrift shop not to long ago for $20. I was tempted because I don't run into that every day! But it was still a heavy as I remembered with a lot of wear. I could have rehabbed it and gifted it, but the young woman next to me was eying it up too. I just said, this is too big for me, and extended it to her. She gave me the biggest smile! I had several black bags, and I like a controlled black hole, like a Monterey Hobo or Shoulder Sac.
I like the Sling, which is roughly the size of the Duffle, minus the hardware. I have one in BT (lol, a while back it was featured traveling to FL). Now if that was a black Sling, whole ‘nother story . . .
If you really want a mahogany duffle post 1994, I am sure another will come along.