The Twilly and Hermes Handles

Agree with everybody, they are very different and I would keep them both.
I find them quite different both color- and style-wise.
They are rather different, one being more geometric print and one an animal print. If you kept both, it wouldn't be duplicative at all except for the similar color scheme (and even then one is more violet, one more cool toned).
That said, if you do decide to let go of the Jardin please let me know!
Oh, I LOVE the way that Jardin looks on your handles! Its a perfect match...and again the one on your noir looks totally different. You could absolutely keep both, they really aren’t too similar.
You should keep both! I think they look different enough to justify keeping them. (Both look gorgeous on your beautiful bags!)
I’ve decided to keep them both! Thank you for being the voice of reason!