UPDATE: I received an email reply from Jewel First stating that all of their Pandora is 100% authentic, but that they will happily return it for me. I have a Pandora box to send it back in, have already filled out the return form, and will be mailing it out this evening. It's unfortunate that it will be at my expense but it's a small price to pay compared to the money I spent on these charms. I'll let you guys know once my credit card is actually refunded.
Last edited: