I had my first almost negative return experience with Sephora a couple weeks ago. I remembered it when I saw that this thread had been bumped... I ordered Too Faced loose glittery shadow and when I got it, I realized it had BIG chunks of glitter (flakes of metal), which I didn't want to put anywhere near my eyes :s
So I went to Sephora, handed it to the lady with the packing slip, and asked for an exchange. I was purchasing a pile of other stuff. She just stared at me and finally she was like "Is is open? Did you use it?" And I'm like "I opened it, put a little on my hand and decided I didn't like it
" So she reaches under the counter and pulls out this big sticker which she very carefully puts across the top to seal it, then she picks it up as if was someone else's dirty underwear or something and tosses it aside. The thing was brand new-- she had to ask if it was opened, because you definitely couldn't tell by looking at it. Even my bf thought she/ the situation was weird 
So I went to Sephora, handed it to the lady with the packing slip, and asked for an exchange. I was purchasing a pile of other stuff. She just stared at me and finally she was like "Is is open? Did you use it?" And I'm like "I opened it, put a little on my hand and decided I didn't like it

