ODE to Kelly 25

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I need some advice .. will be placing an SO soon .. it will def be Kelly 25 but I keep going back and forth between sellier and retourne
I have a back box 28 sellier and will soon have a ebene retourne 25
I think I would prob use retourne more readily bc it’s more casual but
I’m wondering if the sellier is more classic ? Would love to hear some thoughts ! TIa!
Sellier is definitely more classic and formal IMO. It really depends on what you are looking for. Retournè is more casual as you said.
What colour are you going to get?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chrismin
I want something bright — perhaps lime in chèvre ? I feel like I’ll use the retourne more vs considering lasting power ..?
Either way this wouldn’t be a work bag- daily bag
Would be wkds and such
I agree w you about sellier being more formal !

Sellier is definitely more classic and formal IMO. It really depends on what you are looking for. Retournè is more casual as you said.
What colour are you going to get?
 
To all Kelly size 25cm owners...

Can I ask your honest opinion please?
If you have to choose one K25 which colour/leather/hardware would you pick?
(exclude exotic and special order)

Thank you in advance

Timely question as I’ve been on a hunt but down the reseller route. Can’t decide which one of these, assuming they’re out there:
  1. K25 sellier noir chevre (any hardware)
  2. K25 sellier rouge casaque chevre (phw or permabrass)
  3. K25 sellier rose pourpre chevre (any hardware)
... all depending on whether I can find a BBK 28 that’s decent.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fdc and lavida
I want something bright — perhaps lime in chèvre ? I feel like I’ll use the retourne more vs considering lasting power ..?
Either way this wouldn’t be a work bag- daily bag
Would be wkds and such
I agree w you about sellier being more formal !

Just from a personal preference, I prefer sellier over retourne. I only have K25s, all sellier style, and in that size, I have no qualms about using my sellier Ks casually. I may feel differently if I ever get a K28. But I don’t think sellier style would limit your ability to use the bag casually, especially in a bright color like Lime.
 
I really want chèvre so I am def thinking sellier
!

Just from a personal preference, I prefer sellier over retourne. I only have K25s, all sellier style, and in that size, I have no qualms about using my sellier Ks casually. I may feel differently if I ever get a K28. But I don’t think sellier style would limit your ability to use the bag casually, especially in a bright color like Lime.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WingNut and lavida
I really want chèvre so I am def thinking sellier
!
A lime K Sellier in chèvre would be dreamy! While Sellier is more classic, and retourne is more casual, I think the sellier is more beautiful. And chèvre leather is a must for a Kelly SO! Maybe a contrasting interior in gris perle, gris asphalt, or rose pourpre! Would bleu brume be available as an interior color? I also love vert bosphore. Although it might be too dark as an interior color, it would be a beautiful exterior color! Maybe with lime interior.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jenngu
To all Kelly size 25cm owners...

Can I ask your honest opinion please?
If you have to choose one K25 which colour/leather/hardware would you pick?
(exclude exotic and special order)

Thank you in advance

If you’re excluding exotics and special orders, then the only leather left is epsom for Kelly selliers (I personally only like the sellier). Unless you mean Barenia, butler, tadelakt, box etc... but those will be hard to come by.

If we are pretending those rarer leathers are easily available in any colour, then I would choose K25 sellier tadelakt in rose extreme GHW.
 
Top