Ladies...Any RUDE/CATTY/SNIDE/NASTY Remarks about your Birkins or ANY Hermès Purchase

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I know this is not a funny fancy thread but I'ld really like to have your mind on it and perhaps if you'ld like to share your experience about it.
Last monday, I was walking in the streets of my city, Lille, (biggest city at the north of Paris, you've got every shop like LV, Hermès and so on) and a guy shouted insults at me because I was wearing my Kelly.

Now it is important to point out he directly insulted me focusing on my hypothetic wealth.
It is something people often do in France, and I have noticed it does not seem to be the case in other countries. That's because of the 1789 Revolution I guess.

Does it happen in your country ????
It was very rude, very schocking and I feel I was the easy target because I was the blond young girl wearing a skirt, alone with her (also blond) toddler, and there was this Kelly...

I know this is an expensive bag, and I often feel shame for liking expensive items. I've talked about it with some members. But eventhough I can understand the anger of the guy, I feel there was no need to insult me in front of my son, especially since this person does not know me personally.

Has it ever happened to you ?????

I work hard to educate my son, take care of my family everyday, and my husband is literaly killing himself at work. He earned that money.
Plus we do a lot for our local and global environment -I mean ecology-, and we donate a lot to charities and good will.

It's not like I had stolen it from an elderly lady.

I am sorry this happened to you. My wife was insulted in the street of a large US city while carrying a LV shopping bag. There are sorry individuals everywhere. Since the financial crisis of 2008, the flames of class warfare have been fanned in many areas around the globe. I definitely try to keep a lower profile. I do like Hermes because, with the exception of the more highly publicized pieces (Birkins, Kellys, belts with H buckle, CDCs), Hermes usually flies under the radar compared to other brands like LV or Chanel for example. It is not as well known to the public and their products are often more lightly branded.
 
I know this is not a funny fancy thread but I'ld really like to have your mind on it and perhaps if you'ld like to share your experience about it.
Last monday, I was walking in the streets of my city, Lille, (biggest city at the north of Paris, you've got every shop like LV, Hermès and so on) and a guy shouted insults at me because I was wearing my Kelly.

Now it is important to point out he directly insulted me focusing on my hypothetic wealth.
It is something people often do in France, and I have noticed it does not seem to be the case in other countries. That's because of the 1789 Revolution I guess.

Does it happen in your country ????
It was very rude, very schocking and I feel I was the easy target because I was the blond young girl wearing a skirt, alone with her (also blond) toddler, and there was this Kelly...

I know this is an expensive bag, and I often feel shame for liking expensive items. I've talked about it with some members. But eventhough I can understand the anger of the guy, I feel there was no need to insult me in front of my son, especially since this person does not know me personally.

Has it ever happened to you ?????

I work hard to educate my son, take care of my family everyday, and my husband is literaly killing himself at work. He earned that money.
Plus we do a lot for our local and global environment -I mean ecology-, and we donate a lot to charities and good will.

It's not like I had stolen it from an elderly lady.

I read your post and thought about it for a while. I am very sorry this happened to you. I think you did the right thing by not confronting him. But I had two other thoughts.
1. If someone ever makes you uncomfortable again, immediately go into a store or another public place where you feel safe and call the Police. That person is harassing you.
2. Cultivate a confident "don't mess with me" persona when you are walking about in a city environment, especially with your son. The person who confronted you felt you were vulnerable to his "attentions." It's unlikely this person would ever confront a 6'5" strapping guy whose driving a Porsche and has a Rolex.

I am a small woman and have learned the "don't mess with me" strategy by necessity.
 
I am very sorry that you had to go through this... As others said, the problem comes from this guy, not from you! Still, I understand that it shocked you, especially since you were alone with your son and probably afraid for him - if not for you.

As a french, I am really annoyed that our country is going down a "hate money" slope so rapidly... A lot of people here seem to think that money is bad, and that if you have some, you are necessarily a bad person yourself. At the same time, they feel a ferocious jealousy of course... But not for the tons of work or the sacrifices on other things that you have to do day after day to be able to afford your luxuries. That's why we should NEVER be ashamed for loving nice things!!

Saying that, I will go on carrying my Hermès bags PROUDLY because they deserve it, and I deserve them.

(et j'adore Lille, c'est une très belle ville! J'y ai de merveilleux amis et y vais avec plaisir quand j'en ai assez du soleil du sud...)
 
  • Like
Reactions: dangerouscurves
^^^ all true of course, but IMO people like that don't want a rational answer to their jeering remarks, which are given with no rational thought.

I agree. Rational arguments don't work on irrational people. This is someone who is just looking to pick a fight, so better to just not engage.

I agree. I definitely don't engage with jerks like this on the street - or behind the wheel. There are too many seriously disturbed people out there these days.

Yes you are all right. No time wasting with those people.
 
I found it's actually all about jealousy. I have people who only see me few times a year and still gossip about what I'm wearing, I once carried a Prada but they mistaken it as a birkin, then they intentionally told everyone that I spend "xxxxxx" amount on a purse, they even told the cleaning lady who dosen't even do their floor. Then when I got engaged and wear my engagement ring, they start to wear "fake jewelry" with very big stones. I have never carried my birkin in front of them, talking is the way they express their hate, I think it's better just leave them there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lulilu
I found it's actually all about jealousy. I have people who only see me few times a year and still gossip about what I'm wearing, I once carried a Prada but they mistaken it as a birkin, then they intentionally told everyone that I spend "xxxxxx" amount on a purse, they even told the cleaning lady who dosen't even do their floor. Then when I got engaged and wear my engagement ring, they start to wear "fake jewelry" with very big stones. I have never carried my birkin in front of them, talking is the way they express their hate, I think it's better just leave them there.

Truer words have never been spoken.
 
Hi everyone, I hope this is not too controversial...has anyone experienced the following? After buying and carrying my Birkins, other women have taken a keen interest and claim they now own multiples of the bag (or at least been offered them but always decline) plus one or two other styles, all apparently on the same trip (possibly China) but have not yet carried their bags nor shared their stories. In my experience, virtually everyone who has purchased/acquired a Birkin or Kelly is so excited to share their story that it is hard to contain oneself, but to not share and to stare very closely at mine when I'm carrying it makes me wonder. Just a thought.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Elina0408
I rarely share hermes purchases on this forum.
And I don't like birkins. So refuse to buy one.
This doesn't mean I don't know what they are, or try to identify color/leather type by "studying" those I notice irl.
But, I don't rush up to owners/strangers, gabbling my h stories.:hrmm:
Because have things to do. And figure they do, also.
Not sure what you're expecting, from owning these bags? Or from others?:confused1:
 
Top