Thank you so much for bringing this thread to my attention PrairieBagurl. I've read all of your posts and of course went straight to our head of authentication to find out the story. I wish I had a better explanation to come back to you with... and while there is some technical back story, there really is no excuse. This was a matter of our team making a mistake, and then us making a procedural error on the return. This is not something I take lightly at all... and honestly, oddly (although I'm sure some of you may understand) I can't sleep over issues like this one. I started selling on eBay in 1999- and since that day authenticity has been my/ our number one concern. Above everything else we do, if we don't get that right, nothing else matters. We have always offered a lifetime guarantee on authenticity- with zero restrictions... for situations like this one. And thankfully, and because of literally decades of research, study and focus, and with the hundreds of thousands of bags we've sold so far, this has been a very rare occurrence. I am sorry and apologize not only personally but for my team. We will do better. This particular situation has brought up an issue in our process that we are addressing as we speak as well as an opportunity for additional training. Again, thank you for speaking up. "