I would file the claim..
Open the SNAD and cease communicating with the seller.
You tried.. You are not responsible for ANY of those costs..
Their measurements were off and with jewelry 1/2 an inch can mean the difference between it fitting or not..
If the seller agrees to the refund & issues the label after you file a case, they wont be harmed.
The only way they get a defect for it is if they refuse to make it right. It's a case without seller resolution..
It's up to you but I would open the case rather than have the seller try to force you to pay anything for this.. They might even try to withhold original shipping etc.. NONE of the costs should be paid by you..
I suggest you file a case asap and don't communicate with the seller outside the case any more. You shouldn't be liable for the shipping charges either way.
Thank you for the advice given. This was my first SNAD claim ever filed. The seller responded to the SNAD claim with the following email: "I am going to lose over $25.00 plus return shipping just for you to try the bracelet on. You didn't even have the decency to pay for return shipping. It had better be the same bracelet and in the exact same shape I sent it in or I won't accept it and nobody will force me to."
The bracelet would have fit if the measurements were correct. The interior measurements (the part needed to fit the wrist not including the closure was 5.75" compared to the listing interior measurement of 7.09." I paid the second the auction ended, and really wanted this bracelet. I even told the seller I had inquired about the possibility of extending the length, due to the age and lack of parts it could not be done.
I knew with the initial response that they are "getting screwed" it would not be a pleasant return. I am afraid this seller is going to be trouble. I included the pics of the bracelet on the measuring tape for both measurements as well as pics of the bracelet in the SNAD claim.
Any suggestions? I assume photograph with dates the condition of the bracelet, packaged, etc. thank you for your help!
Last edited: