Thanks. Until recently, I didn't know the IRS allowed you to report your sales of all personal items on Schedule D. Previously you were only allowed to report items that were considered investments or collectibles, like jewelry or coins, or large items like cars. For me, it is a godsend that I can report on Schedule D because that means I can offset sales against losses, since I have a carryover, so I'll pay no taxes on my sales.Reporting it on schedule C or D has adv/disadv. With schedule C, you can report it as a business and take other allowable deductions (like if you are running your resale business). You have to pay self employment tax and have to show profits for your venture to be considered a business. You might need to check with your state of residence if you need to get a resale license, etc as there are other multiple regulations that govern business activities in your state. If your sales are truly selling your personal items (some at loss, some for profit), then schedule D is most appropriate, alas more time-consuming in reporting.
The accountant’s reply is correct - it does take a lot of time to enter all those transactions into the tax software. If you have never done it yourself, the charge seems outrageous, but it is not.
I have entered stock sales, pages of them, manually on form 8949 in previous years so I know how time consuming it is.
I'm wondering, there are a lot of items I'm selling from my household that I bought many years ago but don't know the exact date or even the exact year, just know they are long-term. What do I put in the date acquired? I also have no idea what I paid for most of them.
I had always assumed I would do a Schedule C as I'm familiar with it and wanted to be able to write off my expenses.