My first order from SB was damaged goods. They were Joie boots that were on sale, so I thought I had scored, but when I received them... there was a nick in the suede of one shoe, the bottom of the soles looked scratched up, etc. I have no desire to order from them again anytime soon, but they were really nice about the return process.
OMG! I just received Joie boots as well. I paid FULL price and they arrived with scuffs on the sole and scratches on the leather. Someone definitely tried them on and walked a bit before sending them back. I mean I paid almost $400 for them! I'l calling them right away...