With the old return policy, one of my farther away outlets used to be so great about returning bags; it was never a big deal, but for some reason, they aren't adhering to the old policy where if it was bought before September, you have until the 15th or 18th of January to take it back. Meanwhile, another outlet that is closer to me (still a pain to get to with traffic) acts like you are committing a crime when you return anything- it's really off putting to the point where I don't know if it's even worth it. If I have anything else to return before the deadline, I may take it to a FP store. I'm just burned out with how Coach handles returns - like it's the end of the world. I need to shop at department stores from now on and look at selling on ebay as another option. When I took back a bag that wasn't even a year old, they were awful about inspecting the bag when clearly it was new and in mint condition. I started to worry that by multiple SA's and Managers each putting their fingers all over the inside of it, and pulling out the lining the would create a stain or grease spot! At one point, I was sorry I even made the trip!
Our store is similar to yours **sometimes**. It really depends on who you get. If I go at my usual time (Friday morning), I often run into a manager who is really snooty and accuses you of using brand new bags with tags on them even though they look BRAND NEW! It's really amazing.
If I time it to go on Saturday morning however, I find that the manager on call is almost always a nice tall man who is super polite and will bend over backwards to make sure he helps me find items at other stores. Returns are never a problem with him. So now I have given up on going Friday mornings and instead head there on Saturdays if I have to do a return or a special order or anything other than buy something off the shelf!