I'm calling "uncle" on my cat scratched duffle sac. I think it is now the best I can possibly do with it. I've been working on it periodically for the last few years. This bag was mess when I got it. It looked like this:
View attachment 3447423 View attachment 3447424
I can't even remember everything I have done to it. For really deep scratches where the surface of the leather was damaged, I tried several things. I used fine sandpaper and fine steel wool to get the surface flat again. (In a couple spots, I may have sanded a little too much as they have darkened a lot). I tried filling the holes with a couple different types of filler that I bought. One that said it dried clear did a great job filling the holes, but it dried white and left a residue all over the bag, which resulted in this:
View attachment 3447428
I washed it again to get rid of the reside (and the filler). I tried just dabbing in the filler and then using steel wool to smooth it out, but I don't really think it did much. Ultimately, I conditioned again really well and am leaving it as-is. My step-mother expressed an interest in the bag, so I'm going to give it to her. Here is the final result. It definitely has some character, but it still has a lot of life left.
View attachment 3447432
View attachment 3447433
View attachment 3447434