Alas, I failed at removing it on my Sherbourne and a red Regina even rubbing Dawn the grease cutting soap directly onto it.I dunked the sad Beekman today and spent some time wiping down the handle while it was in the wash. I hoped to get the black residue off but as it's drying, it's still there. Any tips on how to clean oils and dirt off of a well worn handle? This was before the dunk: View attachment 4770489View attachment 4770490