Catching up here.
I am now on my second dunk rehab of a british tan bag with “made in the United States” at the bottom of the creed not in the paragraph and, like my first such rehab, the bag which didn’t feel particularly dry before hand has now become stale taffy-like. It is 24 hours since dunk, it is still fairly damp and just got its first CPR application. My question is, is this a quirk of bags of that era when dunked? Something BT bags in general do? I have dunked 2 NYC tabac bags and not had this so it can’t be age. I am just concerned what might happen to my 1996 Sherbourne in BT if I dunk her and this is what BT bags do.
I have a "made in the United States" BT Plaza Large that while distressed, did not rehab as well as my other BT, now that I think of it, are NYC or after 1993. In fact, my NYC Letter Brief (very distressed condition, pre-rehab) and Shoulder Sac, are smooshy, post rehab. So it is not all BT. My BT Oliver is "made in the United States" but never got dunked; it was in virtually unused condition when I got it a few years ago and is just lovely. My 95/96 BT Winnie and Bancroft have lovely leather. So it does make me suspicious for dye lots in the "made in the United States" time frame.
On a side note, I have been wanting to pull out that BT Plaza and see if another app or two of CPR and then and app of Renapur help it out. Will keep you posted. And I have a beat up "made in the USA" Buckle Tote bag in my rehab pile too!
Now that you mention it, my black Station is a made in the United States bag and it has had the stiffest, dryest leather of all my bags after dunked. The second time was better because of all the conditioner I had already applied. It's finally looking and feeling better.
You know, my black Plaza Large, "made in United States" while in good condition, had subtle, universal fading. I dunked it, used Leather Therapy, O Oil, and Blackrock, none of which enhanced the color. I ended up using Saphir recolorant. I was not using CPR or Renapur at that time.
Now I will be taking more careful notes regarding "made in United States" bags.
Fortunately it is black, I think touch up the whole bag with Saphir black colorant will make the bag great again.
As mentioned above, I touched up my black Plaza Large. That stuff was worth every penny imo.