After seeing this, I had to do a search for the dye! I have not been successful yet (just searched tack shops, the one that had dye did not have tan) but when I do find one, I think I can be more brazen about getting this 2 inch long pen mark off the front of my BT station bag! I just LOVE the color that turned out to be!
I don't know if it's silly or not but I usually don't condition before rehabbing.
I never have before, either! But then, I started worrying about dry rot and the old dry straps cracking and breaking... I just did the dryest ones yesterday (3?) and boy, did they suck the conditioner up!
This prompted me to hit my local Tuesday Morning and get the last 2 tubes of Leather CPR. The saleslady said they never know what they're going to get with their trucks, and though this seemed to be coming in fairly consistently, she can't say they'll have more for sure. My first batches were from Marshall's for $5 per tube, but they're more hit and miss than TM! Searched online, and found a shop in-state that has them for less than or equal to TM prices (because they have a sale going on?) with Leather CPR I think 21ish per gallon, but it's almost 2 hours' drive away and I'm not in dire need right now. They do ship, so that might be an option someday. Anyway, sorry for the rambling!

I just get so excited now that I'm back..
I am really pleased with the NYC-made bag that I found at Savers today for $17.50. I thought it was a bucket bag but Hyacinth says that it is a Shoulder Sac 9730 from around 1989.
The color is great and it is in really good shape and pretty clean for its age. It does have some water marks on the bottom and the straps have darkened dirty areas, so I have to decide whether or not to give her a bath and risk losing some color or just surface cleaning her. Any suggestions?
I vote for dunking it.. perhaps with less soap than you usually use? Without soap, you'd at least get the watermarks out (hopefully), with a little, maybe get the dirt out too. I still haven't had a shot at colored bags - can only find blue, black, brown and gray so far, and ebay auctions are just shooting up way out of my budget!
Amen on the rinsing! I can feel it best on the inside suede...when it doesn't feel slick & soapy anymore, I'm done! So far, I've only used Dawn Extra Strength, as most of my bags are older, been in my closet for years (!) and haven't been well cared for til now! I like the idea of using a little hotel bar soap, but haven't tried it...yet.
Oh yes, the rinsing. I also based it on that slick-almost-slimy feeling, but sometimes, I rinse with that little extending spray thing at the sink, and I figure if it doesn't make suds anymore, then I'm good. I've done it where I thought it was fine without the soapy feel, but when I did another quick rinse, suds still came out! I do like the idea of using any non-harsh soap now. I have a LOT of soap from when I couponed, and I never used em cuz I'm now a bodywash gal

I'll still pick and choose which soap to use, but at least some of them will serve their lives' purposes!