Amanda Bynes Thread

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

So they confine her for up to a year, medicate her against her will, keep her out of trouble.

Eventually they will have to turn her loose again. Does anyone believe the cycle won't repeat itself? The minute she doesn't have a "keeper" she goes right back to her old behavior.
 
So they confine her for up to a year, medicate her against her will, keep her out of trouble.

Eventually they will have to turn her loose again. Does anyone believe the cycle won't repeat itself? The minute she doesn't have a "keeper" she goes right back to her old behavior.

But for right now, they can treat her with medication and therapy. If she were my daughter, that's what I would want - I would be grateful for the intervention.
 
I think the new hold will be better for her, but like a PP mentioned, what happens when that is up? She went off her meds this time and went off the rails again, how will they prevent that from happening again? If it's really strictly mental, then nothing is going to help but the meds. I wonder if they are thinking intense therapy might help some of the issues and keep her on the meds. Poor girl. I can't even imagine how scary it would be to be held someplace against your will when you think you are completely sane.
 
I just don't get why everyone continues to blame her parents. We're not talking about a minor child. This is an adult who obviously has a very volatile relationship with her parents. The article posted on the previous page even goes so far as to say that her parents can't restrain her & medicate her against her will, so if she insists on defying them, what exactly are they supposed to do? Comments placing blame on her mother because of her comments last year - that's her belief and that's on her, but who's to say that Amanda would have (or ever was) willingly taking her meds and cooperating with her parents when they were designated her conservator? Maybe it was easier to think that way than to have a daily battle with her daughter to keep on taking meds. Even if her mother never made those comments, would it still be her fault that Amanda had a relapse and stopped taking her meds? No one knows what goes on behind closed doors and this constant insistence that this is all on her parents and finger pointing is ridiculous. If Amanada were 16 years old, then yea, I could see the blame being placed on her parents - but these things never even came to light until Amanada was an adult, out on her own, no longer under their care and watchful eye. Who knows how long they've been dealing with this - I'd say they did a pretty good job since no one knew about this until last year, when Amanda was 26/27 years old.

Celebrities put themselves out there and want our attention, but their families don't ask for this. Amanda's parents aren't granting interviews to Barbara Walters, or the Today Show or Anderson Cooper. They're not discussing these matters with TMZ or Vanity Fair or People Mag. They're not asking for our sympathy or understanding. They're not public figures. As far as I'm concerned, their parenting skills or family choices are no more my business than the ones made by my neighbors or the parents of my children's friends. I wouldn't want total stranger casting doubt or making public proclomations about my parenting skills, and I think its really unfair for anyone to call into question the parenting skills of Amanda Bynes parents - especially when they're not parenting a minor child.

When Robin Wiliams took his own life, did people go knock on his parents door and blame them for his mental state? When Shia LaBeouf showed up on the red carpet with a paper bag over his head, did people start asking where his parents are and why they weren't doing anything? When Joquin Phoenix had an apparent meltdown (later said to be a stunt), were people constantly saying that it was all his mothers fault? When Robert Downey Jr was so high he landed his a$$ in jail, were people calling for his mother to become his conservator? When other adult celebrities admit to being alcoholics or suffering from depression or have other mental health issues, why don't people go running to the parents of those celebrities and start pointing fingers & place all the blame them? That would be ridiculous right? Why? Because they're adults and its not their parents responsibility any more.

Amanda's parents cared enough to come to her "rescue" last year. They got her admitted to a healthcare facility and seemingly back on track. First chance she had, Amanda got out from under their care and took off, suffering a major setback - I wouldn't blame her parents if they don't want to go through that again. None of us know what went on behind closed doors, what wasn't reported on TMZ. In my opinion, they have done nothing to deserve the constant finger pointing that goes on in social media circles, but have actually done all they could - that they are legally able to do - to help their daughter. Its sad and a shame its turned out the way it has, but this constant blame being placed on her parents - or more specifically, her mother - should really stop because its unfair and uncalled for.
 
So they confine her for up to a year, medicate her against her will, keep her out of trouble.

Eventually they will have to turn her loose again. Does anyone believe the cycle won't repeat itself? The minute she doesn't have a "keeper" she goes right back to her old behavior.

And therein lies the problem, complexity and tragedy of mental illness - particularly schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or other more severe mental illnesses. This is why SO many mentally ill people end up on the streets, and why an extremely large percentage of the homeless population are diagnosed as mentally ill. Just think about this situation where a family does not have the means (i.e. money, time, education, the list goes on...) to fight their loved one's illness. It's very sad. Hopefully Amanda will get the help she needs. And hopefully her parents will also get the education and help they need in order to deal with and treat whatever is going on.
 
When Robin Wiliams took his own life, did people go knock on his parents door and blame them for his mental state? When Shia LaBeouf showed up on the red carpet with a paper bag over his head, did people start asking where his parents are and why they weren't doing anything? When Joquin Phoenix had an apparent meltdown (later said to be a stunt), were people constantly saying that it was all his mothers fault? When Robert Downey Jr was so high he landed his a$$ in jail, were people calling for his mother to become his conservator? When other adult celebrities admit to being alcoholics or suffering from depression or have other mental health issues, why don't people go running to the parents of those celebrities and start pointing fingers & place all the blame them? That would be ridiculous right? Why? Because they're adults and its not their parents responsibility any more.

I agree with everything you wrote, but particularly the paragraph above. I see this as a gender issue more than anything. Men have agency and make their own decisions; girls are helpless little lambs and need to be protected, even into adulthood, and how dare Amanda Byne's parents not step into their role of perpetual caretaker for their ADULT child (as if that were even possible, because like I said, she's an adult with money, and until recently had the ability to move about freely). I HATE TMZ for throwing her parents under the bus the way they have. We have no clue what type of pain they are in, what lengths they have gone to to help their daughter. I have known siblings of people with mental illness, and one thing I have learned is that you cannot make an adult mentally ill person do anything (short of getting conservatorship obviously, but those are not easy to get, and not everyone has the resources to make taking care of their mentally ill child their full time job).
 
Oh please, not everyone is blaming her parents.:rolleyes: There's some shade being thrown their way because of their obvious denial at the start of all this about Amanda's issues and what caused it.
 
Amanda's parents cared enough to come to her "rescue" last year. They got her admitted to a healthcare facility and seemingly back on track. First chance she had, Amanda got out from under their care and took off, suffering a major setback - I wouldn't blame her parents if they don't want to go through that again. None of us know what went on behind closed doors, what wasn't reported on TMZ. In my opinion, they have done nothing to deserve the constant finger pointing that goes on in social media circles, but have actually done all they could - that they are legally able to do - to help their daughter. Its sad and a shame its turned out the way it has, but this constant blame being placed on her parents - or more specifically, her mother - should really stop because its unfair and uncalled for.



That is their job. They are her PARENTS. That doesn't change just because you are of legal age. I don't blame her parents for her issues, but having someone who does not believe that their kid has a problem, is certainly not helping the situation. If your child has a drug or alcohol problem, then no I don't think a parent has a responsibility to take charge of their mental health, but if it is a mental health issue then the parent has every responsibility in the world to help them and do what they can to keep them on track. The fact that they have been estranged for so long makes me wonder if it is partly due to previous mental health issues being misinterpreted as teenage rebellion.
 
Top