A resale store is going to extract the pound of flesh with the mark-up. The store and the consignee have to make money in this transaction. The fact that the handle was replaced obviously adds to the price. It also makes me wonder about the rest of the bag if the handle was in such sad shape that it needed replacing. I think in the end, it will be a judgment call by you if it is worth it. No way to tell from the pix the feel of the skins. I don't think that lizard has the longevity of croc and for this price, you can get a croc from some of the trusted resellers.
Don't forget to look for fading and/or color change even though this is black.
My thoughts as well. I have croc so found this one interesting and different. Buying a bag up close and personal is preferable to online and new is always the best although not always possible or practical. And yes, a joke can be miscontsrued when it's read as flat text on a computer screen. In my line of work, a sense of humor and thick skin are necessary.