Wonder anyone got the neon or Barbie pink small? Can share mod shot of this pretty bag? Really lurve that colour but wonder what it will look on person...it's not available from where I m at
19 Flap Bag Club!
- Thread starter raradarling
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
I was mainly a Chanel CF gal when it came to Chanel, but the exquisite-avoiding-gauche gradation of mixed metals and pillowy texture in the C19 kept calling to me, plaintive and longing. The siren song. You know. Even its CC logo is something I love, now.
Serious Q, asking for neutral, cordial, polite opinions: I’ve done my research on the c19 (it’ll likely be medium size for me) IRL and on the Internet (…that bastion of guides, unshakeable truth and hotheaded quarrels; occasionally a voice of measured resources and reason) and I still cannot fully get a grasp on the pros and cons of (shiny) goatskin vs lambskin other than establishing basic facts such as release season/year.
So I’m turning to the learned, stylish, knowledgable sweethearts and walking encyclopaedias of TPF in my time of need: if any kind souls are willing to help a poster out… of lambskin vs goatskin, which do you prefer/recommend, and why? I have access to both and will choose a dark color. Just looking for pro/cons of each (or the ones you own / are familiar with), advantages/disadvantages, what in your subjective opinion looks and wears the best. Note that personally I prefer a lush leather look to a matte finish. Just seeking measured and maybe gushing opinions from the friendly, helpful, pragmatic yet fashionable persons and Chanel lovers here on goatskin vs lambskin c19s.
I would be profoundly grateful.
(Edit: I know there have been a few scattered mentions throughout the 208pg thread but they date from different time periods, and I was hoping to ask your indulgence on what your personal consensus would be now in 2023.
Serious Q, asking for neutral, cordial, polite opinions: I’ve done my research on the c19 (it’ll likely be medium size for me) IRL and on the Internet (…that bastion of guides, unshakeable truth and hotheaded quarrels; occasionally a voice of measured resources and reason) and I still cannot fully get a grasp on the pros and cons of (shiny) goatskin vs lambskin other than establishing basic facts such as release season/year.
So I’m turning to the learned, stylish, knowledgable sweethearts and walking encyclopaedias of TPF in my time of need: if any kind souls are willing to help a poster out… of lambskin vs goatskin, which do you prefer/recommend, and why? I have access to both and will choose a dark color. Just looking for pro/cons of each (or the ones you own / are familiar with), advantages/disadvantages, what in your subjective opinion looks and wears the best. Note that personally I prefer a lush leather look to a matte finish. Just seeking measured and maybe gushing opinions from the friendly, helpful, pragmatic yet fashionable persons and Chanel lovers here on goatskin vs lambskin c19s.
I would be profoundly grateful.
(Edit: I know there have been a few scattered mentions throughout the 208pg thread but they date from different time periods, and I was hoping to ask your indulgence on what your personal consensus would be now in 2023.
Last edited:
I have the lambskin in black and initially I wanted the goat as I Hurd goat is more durable. However when I purchased mine 2 years ago they didn’t have them in goat unless I went the used market. Having used my bag for 2 years, I can say I love the lamb. It’s soft and squishy with some shine but also very durable. It still looks brand new and is a bag I feel comfortable enough hauling to Italy and London on trips.I was mainly a Chanel CF gal when it came to Chanel, but the exquisite-avoiding-gauche gradation of mixed metals and pillowy texture in the C19 kept calling to me, plaintive and longing. The siren song. You know. Even its CC logo is something I love, now.
Serious Q, asking for neutral, cordial, polite opinions: I’ve done my research on the c19 (it’ll likely be medium size for me) IRL and on the Internet (…that bastion of guides, unshakeable truth and hotheaded quarrels; occasionally a voice of measured resources and reason) and I still cannot fully get a grasp on the pros and cons of (shiny) goatskin vs lambskin other than establishing basic facts such as release season/year.
So I’m turning to the learned, stylish, knowledgable sweethearts and walking encyclopaedias of TPF in my time of need: if any kind souls are willing to help a poster out… of lambskin vs goatskin, which do you prefer/recommend, and why? I have access to both and will choose a dark color. Just looking for pro/cons of each (or the ones you own / are familiar with), advantages/disadvantages, what in your subjective opinion looks and wears the best. Note that personally I prefer a lush leather look to a matte finish. Just seeking measured and maybe gushing opinions from the friendly, helpful, pragmatic yet fashionable persons and Chanel lovers here on goatskin vs lambskin c19s.
I would be profoundly grateful.
(Edit: I know there have been a few scattered mentions throughout the 208pg thread but they date from different time periods, and I was hoping to ask your indulgence on what your personal consensus would be now in 2023.
My story is similar. Wanted goat, could only access lambskin when I bought it in Feb 2021 (boutique purchase). It is my favourite CC bag, understated, even in it’s gorgeous ‘boldness’. I am seeing some wear on corners, but I do NOT baby this bag…she gets used, and loved!
@KensingtonUK & @BigOnBags , thanks heaps for your thoughtful replies and info! I’m thrilled you love your bags and that the lambskin worked out perfectly for you!
One thing I remain slightly befuddled about are the varying explanations of ‘shiny goatskin’ (never been explained to me properly tbh) - does anyone have insights?
One thing I remain slightly befuddled about are the varying explanations of ‘shiny goatskin’ (never been explained to me properly tbh) - does anyone have insights?
I don’t get the shiny goatskin but I have had black and burgundy on crumpled calfskin patent leather and it is incredible. I’m surprised they didn’t produce more colors in this leather and I think it was only for one season. It seems to maintain its structure better than lamb or goat but I do use pillows for sturage and organizers for use. No signs of wear at all, look and smell brand new. I always get compliments on them
I have the small in goatskin which I purchased in 2020 from the boutique. It was one of the last 2 seasons which had the goatskin. In-between they had 1-2 seasons in which they made the 19 in lambskin. I definitely wanted the bag in goatskin due to its durability. So far, my 19 still looks like new. No corner wear or scratches. Goatskin has been very carefree and I don’t have to baby it. I know that the lambskin on the 19 has a different coating than the lambskin on the CF, so you don’t have to worry too much, should you get lambskin. However, if I had to make the choice again, I’d still pick goatskin over lambskin.
Hi -I first wanted goatskin but only Lambskin was available so I bought a excellent condition small black goatskin from Fashionphile- when I received it I noticed the wrinkling right away - before sending it back my SA called and said she had a small black lambskin that just came in (21A) series. I Brought it home and I, my husband and friends all liked the Lambskin more! the goatskin was a tad more shiny but the Lambskin has a beautiful sheen (like a light gloss) sent the used goatskin back. After having it for 2 &1/2 years I can say this lambskin on Chanel 19 is very durable. I have NO scratches - NO wrinkling and NO wear!! I do use a bag organizer as It gives my bag a more structured look.I was mainly a Chanel CF gal when it came to Chanel, but the exquisite-avoiding-gauche gradation of mixed metals and pillowy texture in the C19 kept calling to me, plaintive and longing. The siren song. You know. Even its CC logo is something I love, now.
Serious Q, asking for neutral, cordial, polite opinions: I’ve done my research on the c19 (it’ll likely be medium size for me) IRL and on the Internet (…that bastion of guides, unshakeable truth and hotheaded quarrels; occasionally a voice of measured resources and reason) and I still cannot fully get a grasp on the pros and cons of (shiny) goatskin vs lambskin other than establishing basic facts such as release season/year.
So I’m turning to the learned, stylish, knowledgable sweethearts and walking encyclopaedias of TPF in my time of need: if any kind souls are willing to help a poster out… of lambskin vs goatskin, which do you prefer/recommend, and why? I have access to both and will choose a dark color. Just looking for pro/cons of each (or the ones you own / are familiar with), advantages/disadvantages, what in your subjective opinion looks and wears the best. Note that personally I prefer a lush leather look to a matte finish. Just seeking measured and maybe gushing opinions from the friendly, helpful, pragmatic yet fashionable persons and Chanel lovers here on goatskin vs lambskin c19s.
I would be profoundly grateful.
(Edit: I know there have been a few scattered mentions throughout the 208pg thread but they date from different time periods, and I was hoping to ask your indulgence on what your personal consensus would be now in 2023.
I love my 19. The lambskin is not that fragile. This is my first lambskin bag that I enjoy wearing. Still in like new condition. 
I checked my 19 and the seams are to the side and not noticeable…this isn’t right. If a boutique buy, reach out to your SA. I understand they will do repairs if warranted. Note your bag will be gone for quite some time. Otherwise maybe a qualified leather repair shop? Leather Surgeons in the US is highly reputable.
came for the 19 lambskin pic, stayed for that darling red Chanel cardholder xI love my 19. The lambskin is not that fragile. This is my first lambskin bag that I enjoy wearing. Still in like new condition.
View attachment 5900385