"What was I thinking?" Bag purchases you regret...

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I regret buying my Mulberry oversized Alexa. Got it during the Net-a-Porter sale for $1100. A great price for the oversize but I should've held out for the regular Alexa. And wouldn't you know it, that dang Alexa went on sale a few weeks later when I had already started using my Oversized one. It's just too big (weird for me to say given i love BIG bags) but mainly it's hard to get in and out of. The flap is heavy and the magnet clasp is so strong. I feel like I'm going to rip the leather. Also the straps are too long for me to carry crossbody. At it's shortest, it hits me almost at my knees. Why?!

This. You spoke of my mind. I also got mine from NAP and sold it for all the reasons you stated.
 
Very thought-provoking post!

Feel the same about RM. Sold all mine. RM and MK at least hold their value. For Kata Spade or most of the Coach you will lose money big time if you sell them.

Update:
For more than six months, I have regretted selling this bag. As more time passes, more regret. I found one pre-loved on eBay and just re-purchased the same style of bag I sold. I now have it back, and in total, have spent $100-200 more than the original cost of full retail price for the bag.

For that price, though, I know I will never part with this bag.

So what happened?

I moved, and my needs changed. Importantly, I KNEW this at the time I sold - yet sold under those flukey circumstances because I was infatuated with the Hindmarch bag and was able to get one on a pre-move visit. I carried the Hindmarch several times, but it never worked as well for me as I hand hoped. It is amazing quality and some of the most beautiful leather I've stroked or sniffed, yet it really doesn't hold much, so by the time I had wallet, small pouch, and eyeglass case, it felt (over) stuffed). As I settled into a very different lifestyle - with daily commute on public transit, I yearned for the Pandora: sturdy zips, three carrying options, outer zip pockets for transit pass and phone; bomb-proof goatskin leather (to borrow another tPFer's description from the Pandora thread).

Lesson One: Impulse bag-decisions -- buying AND selling -- are bad news at times of transition. With a goal of buying what fits the life you HAVE, it's silly to either buy or sell before knowing what your new life will be like. There's a window there when it's easy to project the life you want or think you may have - the very vision of your new life that you MUST have to get yourself through the upheaval - before knowing how it will all play out. At the same time, it is SOOOO TEMPTING - to want to be prepared with JUST THE RIGHT BAG. Don't do it: you don't know until you know. Live the new life, learn the routines - what's the same (not much)? what's different (well, everything). What matters most to me now? THEN decide.

Lesson Two: With fantasy-like exposure to more high end bags than I could ever want, I got into Balenciaga. Not hordes of them in every color -- but a good, select, pre-loved few. I am Bal-content, not looking for more (and grateful that it's the older bags that call to me instead of the ones I can visit just down the street). Why is this important? The quality: as a tPF friend said, "when I can carry one of my Bals, why would I choose a 'lesser' bag? She's right - not because of status or labels - but because of quality and workmanship. It feels different, not in a good way, to carry a bag that doesn't have that. Now, some very expensive bags don't feel as good as they should for the price (some newer-year Bals, anyone?) and plenty of less expensive / mid-tier bags have supreme workmanship (the Frye languishing in my closet is one...).

A few things: I have access to hordes of bags. Balenciaga, Givenchy, and others that don't move me as much. With this, I learned a few more things:

1) my price ceiling has NOT returned to $2K - despite several attempts. I purchased full-price Bals and felt sick about it, so back they went. I did this several times, and know for certain that the original lesson of the price point - not wanting to go there again - has remained with me.

2) I am a vulture for a deal on a pre-loved bag that began at this price point. i am hooked on that level of quality, so I shop for it more patiently. More or less. Sometimes less. My sweet spot is right around $1,000 -- prefer to go lower, yet will also go a bit higher for the magical mix of infatuation, function, and value.

3) Loving one style in a line does not mean embracing the whole line. I did this shortly after discovering RM: in the buying-frenzy so well known to anyone who had an RM phase, I bought many RMs, many styles, few to none of which work for me now. Can I add here that -- but for one or two -- I regret ALL (20-ish) of those, and they sit quietly in storage? The price point is such that it's easy(ier) to rationalize buying too many - a few hundred dollars doesn't feel as bad, so the risk lies in spending that few hundred bucks WAAAYYYY too many times. I'm better off with bags that cost more/ make me think more/ and that hurt more when I make a mistake. Enough to want to avoid the mistake (see: think more). So - that $1,000-ish price point I regretted getting to (prior post) turns out to be just the right place to be - to find joy and value - without the insanity of buying ALL the more affordable bags.

4) I learned that it's OK to love-love-love some styles and feel unmoved by others to the point of ignoring them completely. Rather than being a 'Bal Girl' or a Givenchy Girl' - I am a 'neutral-color-City-or-Velo-with-Giant-21-rosegold-or-silver-HW Bal Girl'; and a 'goatskin-sugar-leather-Pandora-with-silver-HW-Givenchy-Girl".

I also learned more about selling options and have resolved to clear out storage. (I sold the Ferregamo Sofia and the Chanel bucket - because, despite their quality and beauty, they didn't work for my life, before or after the move). One of these days...
 
Any bag I didn't 100% love. My purchases are often impractical in others' eyes, but they put a smile on my face and they work for me. Bags that I didn't 100% love, bought because they were practical or filled a need at the time typically don't get worn after that need passes. They languish in the closet because I spent X amount of money on it, what happens if that need arises again, and I don't want to spend money on another bag with the same need.
 
Why do you think you would have carried the DA Neverfull more?

The DA and DE are both more subtle.

Where I live, the mono is too in your face.

I usually only carry my mono bags if we go into one of the nearby cities.

If I lived in an area where it was more acceptable to have pricey handbags, I would carry my mono all day, everyday. I think it is such a pretty print. :smile1:
 
Yes. This was when I was in that initial stage of wanting bags last year and didn't own a dreamy perfect everyday bag yet because I couldn't pull the trigger on the price.

1. I bought a frrry small rivet a aqua tote because it was on sale and the aqua colour was appealingly unique. It's a clever bag with nice leather and designer ideology but what I've realised is that if it doesn't fit my lifestyle, it's useless to me. I tried to like it but ultimately I got really stressed out because I never really use it. It's too small for me and I've discovered what I truly like and need.
I don't like totes unless they're for work and more than just basic and I already have three. I like the security of zips and want functional compartments. I find the colour too bright and hard to match even though I can wear my yellow/green colourblock bag just fine. I prefer longer straps and like to wear my bags hitting me at my hip. The lining also has stains from the hardware and storage. I didn't even try selling it because I'd never get as much back for a relatively unknown brand. I really wish I'd gotten an RM mini Mac or 5-zip instead; I could have probably sold that easily or even kept it. I was worried the mini Mac would be too small, reluctant to pony up for the Mac and concerned with the quality.
I struggled with just throwing the frrry bag away to feel relieved and kept thinking about what I could have used the money for instead. I just gave it to my sister to use and even looking at it makes me unhappy. I don't think she'll like it either for the same reasons.

2. A Raoul small black crossbody clutch with unique, adjustable strap with hardware. Impulse purchase on an app. It turned out way too small, even as a clutch. I'm huge now so it makes me look even huger and once I upgrade my phone, it'll really be useless to me. Still, I don't mind keeping this as much. I was really attracted to the smooth and stiff black leather. Honestly if it was four times its size, I'd probably love it.

3. A MBMJ What's the T tote. I don't like totes as much. People always commented on this bag (the recognisable brand) and the beautiful red colour but it just didn't do it for me in the end. I swapped it for a large Laurige slate bag that my sister wasn't using because it was too stiff for her and am much happier for it.

I have 10 bags. I don't really regret my other bags that I don't use as much (vintage small Gucci coated canvas tote, red kangaroo skin crossbody purse) but there have been times after getting my dreamy everyday bag that I wished I could trade them in just for another bag from the same brand. I think the lesson here is not to buy bags just because you can't justify or afford the bag/style you really want. Acquisition must be well thought out. Also, your taste will settle. You won't know what works for you right off the bat.

Sorry for the word spillage; I guess I had lots to get off my chest. :amazed:
 
Too many to list but generally the bags I regret ever buying have the following features:
1. logos - want to be more discreet in my life
2. snap closures or open top
3. oversized and heavy


Similar to another poster, I don't conform to any one brand.
 
I regret the Chanel coco shine small flap, givenchy Antigona small size and the celine trapeze. The first two I've never used and the trapeze was from a preowned website but I never used it. All listed for sale now. No doubt, I'll make a loss on all of them.[emoji17]
 
The DA and DE are both more subtle.

Where I live, the mono is too in your face.

I usually only carry my mono bags if we go into one of the nearby cities.

If I lived in an area where it was more acceptable to have pricey handbags, I would carry my mono all day, everyday. I think it is such a pretty print. :smile1:

Yes, I completely understand what you are saying and I was thinking that this is what you would say. I also own mono bags and love how they look, but I sometimes feel self conscious wearing them locally.
 
The DA and DE are both more subtle.

Where I live, the mono is too in your face.

I usually only carry my mono bags if we go into one of the nearby cities.

If I lived in an area where it was more acceptable to have pricey handbags, I would carry my mono all day, everyday. I think it is such a pretty print. :smile1:

I think you should carry & enjoy it -,since you like the style and suits your lifestyle. By keeping the rest of your outfit, smart and simple, the mono can look elegant and understated.
 
I love this thread b/c I'm an impulse buyer and do a lot of online shopping so its nice to know that I'm not the only one with tons of regrets! My most recent bag regrets that I still own are:

Reed Krakoff Boxer - I have (and love) an Atlantique and bought a Boxer from NM which I returned. A few months later I saw a similar bag at the Woodbury Commons outlet and bought it. It has not held up well at all, doesn't really fit my stuff, and now just sits on a shelf.

Balenciaga Town in Red Thullian - I do like this bag and I use it occasionally but the reddish-pink color is hard to wear (or use year round) and I wish I had gotten a City or a Velo. The Town isn't quite big enough.

Mansur Gavriel bucket bag in rosa saffiano - I think I just got caught up in the hype and wanted to get my hands on a bucket bag. Again, I do use it sometimes but it isn't a practical bag. I don't really like the bucket style, the leather is really stiff, and it is hard to find anything in it.
 
Top