"What was I thinking?" Bag purchases you regret...

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I regret buying several Coach and Cole Haan from Rue La La just because of the "thrill". I love these brands, but not the choices I made. They were rushed and no research was put into it. I wish I had saved my money and gotten just a couple of premier instead.

One in particular was a Coach Kristin hobo in pebble leather. That thing was HEAVY! Sold on ebay this past year.
 
I'd have to say my Chanel Black Baby Cabas and Miu Miu Black Patent Matelasse.

Though I love them both from afar, the giant medallion on the Cabas really weighs it down. I'm tempted to remove but then that would probably wreck resale value if I still don't like it.

The patent Matelasse is so beautiful but the patent coating seems fragile and just seems overall impractical (I don't have the patience to baby my bags and like to use the crap out of them!) Plus they are both HUGE. What was I thinking???

Oh well, live and learn, at least they were both bought preloved :angel: :whistle:
 
I regret buying several Coach and Cole Haan from Rue La La just because of the "thrill". I love these brands, but not the choices I made. They were rushed and no research was put into it. I wish I had saved my money and gotten just a couple of premier instead.

One in particular was a Coach Kristin hobo in pebble leather. That thing was HEAVY! Sold on ebay this past year.

I think Rue La La's business model depends on this. It's on sale, I gotta have it before it goes back to regular price, click click click, it's mine! Woohoo! But yeah, the nature of the short and limited stock sales don't really give you a lot of time to think or research it before you buy. They're depending on the thrill-seeking shopper and the impulse buyer.

On the subject of heavy Coach bags, yeah, my Legacy Turnlock Tote is in that category. It's beautiful and functional, but it is SO heavy even when completely empty.
 
I hate to admit it but my regret would have to be the MJ Stam. It was my first premier designer piece and it was in like new conditions (with tags and all) for a good price, so I figured why not? Clearly didn't think this one through. -_-

Later I realized the blue actually doesn't match with anything and the bag itself is really heavy just by itself. It's still sitting in my closet, but I'm thinking of selling it back on ebay soon. Oh well, lesson learned.
 
I regret buying a Black Givenchy Pandora (medium), bought for full price @ Barney's.

I loved it and wore it every day for more than a month. The first day I had the urge to change out of it, I was horrified: "how could I spend that much and want to carry ANYTHING but this bag?"

For nearly a year, it sat - taunting me. I stopped carrying it with intent to sell. I had never sold a bag, so I was stuck: no idea where or how to begin.

During that time, I discovered tPF, and Bonanza, and Tradesy (knew about eBay, and never wanted to go there..). I bought some used bags - learned a bit about selling. Sold a couple of iThings on Glyde.com, and learned that Tradesy uses an identical approach. I felt OK about listing such an expensive bag with their system.

After many months, I wore her again - she was the PERFECT bag for whatever it was I needed that day. I fell back in love with her, and put her back into rotation. I decided to keep her and love her the way she deserved - to free myself from the guild and let myself love her. I removed the sale listing

Many months later, I received email, saying "Your Bag has Sold for $,$$$". To this day, I do not know how the listing I removed became active again. I called them; learned I could cancel the sale), I deliberated (should I just sell it or not???). I sold her, and I don't regret it.

So why do I regret buying the bag I loved--- then felt guilty about -- then let myself love again? Because it raised my threshold. That bag cost >$2k -more than double what I had spent for any single bag prior to buying her. Thanks to Panda, I learned that I do not want to be at that price point again -- or that if I am tempted (and believe me I have been) - that the happiness to be found there is not proportionately greater. Or, if it feels like the joy is greater, so, too will be the guilt!. (even now, I am coveting a Ferragamo Sookie. See thread: Celebrate - What we Did Not Buy)

It was hard to part with her, but I have learned that I can live without her. (I also purchased Anya Hindmarch maxi zip satchel as a replacement - for less than half what Pandora cost. Still too much, but less-too-much).

What I regret is that Pandora raised my price ceiling. I can now rationalize other purchases with this: "It is not $2,000 - it is only half that!" (see: vintage Chanel bucket, large Ferragamo Sofia, and Anya Hindmarch maxi zip satchel - all four-digit purchases, among many other sub-four digit purchases).

So, this.

Boy, I can relate to your story! My first high end designer experience was with Chanel. I rented the black perforated drill from Bag, Borrow or Steal to use on a trip to Paris. It was a great bag, large enough to hold everything including guide books and maps. Loved it so much I ended up buying it from ebay when it was on sale at a great price ($750). Used it to travel to Paris the next year, but truthfully, only used it for traveling. Found it much too large for everyday, and at 5'2", I was constantly fishing for things. Also found that it was too far out of the mainstream box to resell. I tried a high end consignment shop, ebay (where it was very competitively listed_snobswap, threadflip, even craigslist (where people were offering my $600!), before just selling it yesterday on tradesy. I made a little money but no killing. My other bags from Chanel are also a bit out of the box style wise, with the exception of a bronze WOC, which I just recently bought (I started a thread showing my collection on TPF). I guess if you want to resell you really have to go after the popular styles. But I don't buy a bag with that in mind -
 
I regret trading a boatload of my purses for a Bottega Veneta. The bag is really nice, with soft leather, but I don't use it now at all. I tried selling it on a few sites and no one wants it. Now I'm stuck with this bag I don't want and not sure I even like anymore. I could use the money by selling it, but finding a buyer is a problem!
 
Seasonal Mulberry bags from sale. Sooner or later I notice I was tempted only by the brand and price, not the bag itself. I use a couple of times, get bored and sell. Stupid. I have told myself its better to buy one more expensive bag that I really love than settle for something else for the price.
 
Before I started buying luxury brands, I used to buy adidas Originals bags and Lacoste bags. The adidas Originals after a month or so started peeling (and I was wondering why the heck I had these weird colored flakes on my clothes). I got into the Lacoste craze since everyone in Manila was gaga over them. I used to baby these bags to death (like I remember shoving one under my shirt and running like mad across the soccer field to avoid the rain. LOL.)

Waste of money (well my parents' money during that time.)
 
I hate to admit it but my regret would have to be the MJ Stam. It was my first premier designer piece and it was in like new conditions (with tags and all) for a good price, so I figured why not? Clearly didn't think this one through. -_-

Later I realized the blue actually doesn't match with anything and the bag itself is really heavy just by itself. It's still sitting in my closet, but I'm thinking of selling it back on ebay soon. Oh well, lesson learned.
LOL. I got the aubergine one recently and haven't used it yet. I LOVED it when I saw it in the store, but the gold hardware makes it very heavy. I did get it in black/silver on ebay last year and in navy/silver at Bloomies; those aren't as heavy because I think the silver is lighter than the gold in terms of the hardware. It's such a beautiful bag and so disappointing to have to return it, but I totally understand. It's awfully heavy, even with very little stuff in it!
 
LOL. I got the aubergine one recently and haven't used it yet. I LOVED it when I saw it in the store, but the gold hardware makes it very heavy. I did get it in black/silver on ebay last year and in navy/silver at Bloomies; those aren't as heavy because I think the silver is lighter than the gold in terms of the hardware. It's such a beautiful bag and so disappointing to have to return it, but I totally understand. It's awfully heavy, even with very little stuff in it!


Ooo, the colors you got sound lovely! I'm sure I'd carry mine more if the color was more versatile :(

I have the blue/silver, so I'm just imagining how heavy the gold bags would be - yikes! On the bright side, carrying these make for good arm workouts, lol
 
Ooo, the colors you got sound lovely! I'm sure I'd carry mine more if the color was more versatile :(

I have the blue/silver, so I'm just imagining how heavy the gold bags would be - yikes! On the bright side, carrying these make for good arm workouts, lol


Oh, I have blue/silver. It is the navy/silver combo? I snapped up the last one about a year ago. It is my favorite color stam. Good arm workout is a good way to look at it!
 
My Chanel Ritz flap. I fell in love with it when I saw a photo of it here, but since it's a seasonal design, I was a couple years late. So, I did a search for it obsessively and found a "like new" one online. I bought it right away. It came all nice and new. But... I don't love it as much as I think I would. I love the design and the compartment. It's just not the size that I like. It's too east-west to my liking. I just can't bring myself to wear it. Plus, it's in patent, which is my least favorite type of material. It sits in my closet unused. :(
 
  • Like
Reactions: Debbie65
The only bag I bought that I didnt like and gave away was this huge color block quilted Aldo tote. It looked cute at first and I used it like 3 times total before giving it away so it was definitely a "what was I thinking?" bag.
 
Top