I didn't think my question would bring such strong responses from certain members. Moderator please feel free to shut this thread if you want to. Thanks to everyone who kindly contrubuted to it but It's heading in the wrong direction than what I intended it to be. Which is a light friendly chat about a lovely bag to a lovely event.
flaunting? Depends what kind of guests will be at the wedding! That could be the norm.
A wedding is a formal affair whether it's in a garden, down the local pub or a hotel ballroom. Always better to take a small bag or clutch - can be hermes if you wish.
Only time i would take a birkin is if it is exotic skin and 25cm
why is carrying it to a wedding crass but carrying them 364 other days of the year not crass? Who said they're trying to impress anyone? Not everyone buys a birkin to show off. It's pretty rude to assume that the op is a grandstanding show off.
Op, i do not think a birkin works for anything other than a casual luncheon wedding as its a casual tote, not because you'd be showing off. [emoji4]
Hi ladies,
Are birkins appropriate for a wedding? Have any of you wear your birkins to weddings? If so what size/leather/color combo did you use?
The current banter proves my original point, OP. Buy/wear what you want, and the feel sorry for those self-appointed arbiters of what's ridiculous and tacky who judge others at weddings instead of celebrating the newlyweds, enjoying their date, or shaking a tail feather.
I've been off the forum for many months now, and was just catching up. This thread made me laugh a little so I wanted to comment as a guy.
My lady has taken different B30s to several weddings, and an Hermes Catenina to other weddings. So yes, I'd say it's totally fine to bring a Birkin to some weddings (but obviously, not all weddings).
It's pretty easy to figure out which weddings are Birkin appropriate: if the guys don't have to wear a tie, then you can relax the purse down too. Think vineyard with a lot of Silicon Valley types; it's going to be a lot less formal.
The Catenina is clutch-like, so it is a fantastic evening bag (in certain colors). Very versatile since it has a beautiful, delicate chain that can be long, short, or hidden...
I'm not worried about a guest upstaging the bride... I just don't see how that is possible when the bride is wearing a huge, poofy white dress. And wouldn't you want successful, put together people at your wedding? I see it as adding some extra glamour, not a zero-sum game versus the bride.
Last point: most people don't recognize Hermes products anyhow (and I say this having spent handily on H). So really the decision to bring a Birkin or other H purse is about style, not meaning (I.e. no need to worry whether it is okay to have the most expensive bag at the party, possibly costing more than some wedding dresses for younger folks).
PS I've seen a lot of unhappy clutches at weddings... I honestly don't know where these clutches come from, but you've surely seen them... Sequins fallen off, threads loose, etc.
If it is a choice between a dark, b25/b30 Birkin for a formal, evening wedding versus a ratty, back-of-the-closet clutch -- I would totally prefer the quality one.
Not because I want to upstage anyone but because I only have H bags these days anyway.
I've been off the forum for many months now, and was just catching up. This thread made me laugh a little so I wanted to comment as a guy.
My lady has taken different B30s to several weddings, and an Hermes Catenina to other weddings. So yes, I'd say it's totally fine to bring a Birkin to some weddings (but obviously, not all weddings).
It's pretty easy to figure out which weddings are Birkin appropriate: if the guys don't have to wear a tie, then you can relax the purse down too. Think vineyard with a lot of Silicon Valley types; it's going to be a lot less formal.
The Catenina is clutch-like, so it is a fantastic evening bag (in certain colors). Very versatile since it has a beautiful, delicate chain that can be long, short, or hidden...
I'm not worried about a guest upstaging the bride... I just don't see how that is possible when the bride is wearing a huge, poofy white dress. And wouldn't you want successful, put together people at your wedding? I see it as adding some extra glamour, not a zero-sum game versus the bride.
Last point: most people don't recognize Hermes products anyhow (and I say this having spent handily on H). So really the decision to bring a Birkin or other H purse is about style, not meaning (I.e. no need to worry whether it is okay to have the most expensive bag at the party, possibly costing more than some wedding dresses for younger folks).
PS I've seen a lot of unhappy clutches at weddings... I honestly don't know where these clutches come from, but you've surely seen them... Sequins fallen off, threads loose, etc.
If it is a choice between a dark, b25/b30 Birkin for a formal, evening wedding versus a ratty, back-of-the-closet clutch -- I would totally prefer the quality one.