I need some advice... I am looking to join the Regina club here

and am debating between two bags I found. Both were made in the 90s and have already been authenticated here. One is black and the other is beige/white.
I would love to get both but I’m trying to not to that..
Black/dark brown is typically my default because they would match everything and easier to touch up in terms of colour (though I haven’t actually tried yet..). However, the seller might be questionable- even though the bag itself has been authenticated, I was also warned that the seller has very recently listed some fakes. So I don’t know how I feel about buying from her....
The beige bag is so cute! And the condition is supposedly lightly used (the pictures seem to corroborate but you never know). However, I bought a light colour Devon bag earlier this year and it was a lot of work to clean up! Even though I now love that bag and use it occasionally (nervously, I should add -I wouldn’t want to risk staining it even if it isn’t totally perfect)
I should add that I do have a black Winnie (and still regret not getting the beige one immediately when the seller offered it to me after I had bought the black). I think those two bags are quite similar in size?
Or I could skip the Reginas and just get the new trail bag???

what do you all think? I think I need to hear more points of view before I can make a decision!!! Thanks a lot for reading!