I just received my goatskin nightingale too. Although it slouches not as soft as lamb, but I adore it too. I had a calf nightingale but just sold it. It's smooth but slightly heavier than goat. I feel that goat is more durable, and it will get soften with use
Ahhh now you have me convinced on the goat leather then May we get to see mod pictures or/and close up pictures of the goat leather?