The JADE thread!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Has anyone brought from GREENDEERbymui on Etsy?

I saw one person here did years ago and they did their own home testing but I was just wondering if anyone recently can attest to the quality and if it’s really untreated. They have such cute traditional pieces mixed a slight modern twist.
I have no experience, but their items looks pretty. I didn't check what their return policy is... for me, I'd be willing to take a chance as long as I can return for full refund including shipping if the item is not as described, or at least exchange/credit if it is as described but I cannot fit it.
Okay ladies, I need your help deciding on which bangle to purchase. Both are the same price at $2k (are these way overpriced?!) each and this would be my forever splurge piece. The princess is plain and timeless but the D shaped with white and green speaks to me as well.
It's so hard to say about pricing! Jade prices depend so much on generalities and fine points. Is there room to bargain? Is it from the same seller? Have you had a chance to try them on? Do you know in detail how they came to that price? Translucency, color, grain, flaws? Is there any cotton or stone lines or chips? The D shape looks like it maybe has slightly more translucency, but the princess looks like more even coloring, maybe? Are they the same weight, size? Princess tends to be more expensive because it takes more jade to make. I love a good chubby princess, my preference is for 10-11mm. In D shape, I like a 15mm width with a 4-6mm thickness.

For looks, my bias would be for the D - I love white/green flowers, but for wear, I love princesses. Princess bangles are actually easier on/off for me and I can go down in size for them. I like the way they settle on the wrist and rock -- but for some, that is less comfortable as the flat on the D spreads the weight out more evenly.


My current bangle. I see myself wearing this one for a while. Also, it’s quite painful to take off, which is rare. I can slip off a 49 mm oval bangle like it’s nothing. This one is around a 50 mm (it was advertised as a 51, but no way is it a 51) and it hurts like nothing else. I put it on, and I think i will keep it on until my hand heals.

Just out of curiosity I slipped on cotton candy, a 51mm bangle, and no discomfort at all. I’m not sure if it’s the specific cut of this carved bangle, or maybe it’s even smaller than I suspect, but this one left my hand aching.
So pretty on the wrist! The coloring looks so nice! Interesting about the measurement differences.. have you gotten your own calipers yet? Haha, I picked up a digital one from amazon awhile back when I bought a bangle that was advertised as a 51mm but when I got it, it was so big! It was actually around a 54mm. I kept it, though because for the price, the quality was just amazing. I loved the color and it has the best chime.
 
Here are some reposts....

The price difference between these 2 bangles is HUGE (different sellers). Based on some pictures, it's hard to see what the difference would be, but the bangle on the left has finer grain, better translucency. The left/top one is a 52.2mm and about 10mm even thickness. The right/bottom is a 54mm, but taller than it is thick. Both have really clear & clean chimes.

MuO72ZV.jpg


bvsZPiM.jpg


Here's the left/top with another bangle that has fabulous translucency but it has 3 major cracks - no chime, needs to be banded. Because of the flaws, the bangle on the right was steeply discounted (different sellers).

YYWNlGp.jpg
 
I have no experience, but their items looks pretty. I didn't check what their return policy is... for me, I'd be willing to take a chance as long as I can return for full refund including shipping if the item is not as described, or at least exchange/credit if it is as described but I cannot fit it.

It's so hard to say about pricing! Jade prices depend so much on generalities and fine points. Is there room to bargain? Is it from the same seller? Have you had a chance to try them on? Do you know in detail how they came to that price? Translucency, color, grain, flaws? Is there any cotton or stone lines or chips? The D shape looks like it maybe has slightly more translucency, but the princess looks like more even coloring, maybe? Are they the same weight, size? Princess tends to be more expensive because it takes more jade to make. I love a good chubby princess, my preference is for 10-11mm. In D shape, I like a 15mm width with a 4-6mm thickness.

For looks, my bias would be for the D - I love white/green flowers, but for wear, I love princesses. Princess bangles are actually easier on/off for me and I can go down in size for them. I like the way they settle on the wrist and rock -- but for some, that is less comfortable as the flat on the D spreads the weight out more evenly.



So pretty on the wrist! The coloring looks so nice! Interesting about the measurement differences.. have you gotten your own calipers yet? Haha, I picked up a digital one from amazon awhile back when I bought a bangle that was advertised as a 51mm but when I got it, it was so big! It was actually around a 54mm. I kept it, though because for the price, the quality was just amazing. I loved the color and it has the best chime.
The two bangles are from the same seller. I was originally set to purchase the D shaped and negotiated a slight discount which made it come down to the same price as the princess. In terms of stone lines, the seller stated there are none. This is an online seller from Taiwan (I’m in the US) so it would be a risk buying without trying first.
 
I posted last week about two bangles that I was deciding between but ended up going with my gut and getting something completely different. I couldn’t stop thinking about the glow and translucency.

So, this is actually a push present and my husband thinks I should hold off wearing it until we get closer to the due date. But I’m thinking why wait when it’s jade and meant for good luck/protection? What do you all think? Silly superstition or yes since the purchase is meant to celebrate baby, it should be for later?

Here are some pics of the beauty.

79DB500A-150F-4D97-9D6A-00A1754974D1.jpegEA9D65B5-D8F4-4F75-92B4-9C9E6363FDEA.jpegBD3D079C-477E-4F4E-BD66-0C29D4B83857.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I posted last week about two bangles that I was deciding between but ended up going with my gut and getting something completely different. I couldn’t stop thinking about the glow and translucency.

So, this is actually a push present and my husband thinks I should hold off wearing it until we get closer to the due date. But I’m thinking why wait when it’s jade and meant for good luck/protection? What do you all think? Silly superstition or yes since the purchase is meant to celebrate baby, it should be for later?

Here are some pics of the beauty.

View attachment 5731812View attachment 5731813View attachment 5731816
I'd be wearing it immediately! How could you resist? I really like the dreamy quality to this jade. It's the perfect choice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cool Breeze
Top