This ad does more for me!!! Gorgeous elephant, gorgeous scarf!!!!
Hey, I need that scarf!!
All great points. As devil's advocate, I would say this:
(1) this ad was deliberately composed, to the very last detail (like a Jeff Wall piece of art!) - so it is not accidental that the pale indian sky "fades" down into her white suit. A different spin is that the H products are materializing out of the air and elements - a natural reflection, or embodiment, of the Indian landscape. It flows directly out of nature - is drawn entirely from nature, and is organic (not jarring, contrasting).
(2) there is symmetry here that draws the eye to the whole ad: the colours on the elephant eyes is the colour on and under their feet - the eye is drawn to all of these colours. The trunks and her legs draw the eye vertically, and the orangey eye - H logo - orangey eye move it laterally.
(3) the warmth and darkness of her skin tone pop against the white sky/clothes, creating an analogy to the elephant (eye/feet).
(4) the real message to me (what POPS out of this ad) is: COLOUR!! Compare and contrast to Kelly caleche. This ad campaign is about India, and the glorious, vibrant colours it is known for. This ad messages to me that 2008 is a year about bright, bold colours. In a sense, the white RTW is a really secondary piece. It's as if they don't want to draw attention away from the colour. The white is not bold white - again, it is more muted (off whites?) and blended almost naturally into the landscape, creating a canvas for the colour, the artistry. (And those flower petals!! new H scents, anyone?? The ad is almost fragrant!)
(5) - ok, I'll stop... :shame:
It reminds me of this photo.. Dress is by Dior
Photo taken in the late 1950s
I wish I worked at their ad agency... hey, a girl can dream right?