Those shoes are on sale at
Nordstrom for $118. Not sure what you paid for yours?? I think they are really cute, but natural vachetta does not wear well, especially from the oil in your skin. I would spray them well if you decide to keep them. I almost bought them today, but I changed my mind because of this.
I personally find that size Carly too small for the type of bag it is. I almost bought the chili one that was on sale at Lord and Taylor, but I tried it and decided I couldn't deal with the size. I do like the Bridgit, which is really small, but somehow that bag has more structure and is "organized" to me with all the compartments and pockets, whereas the Carly I just find to be a lump. You might consider the slim Carly. I think this is a better size....I almost bought that one a while ago after trying it on. It's nice!!