Oh yes, I can relate to the weable art concept and its contribution to self expression. I started collecting in 2011/12 and have since amassed over 100 scarves, with over 30 of them pink alone. I wish I was a giraffe, I could wear them all at once. And it was FOMO most definitely in those early years. Plus, the heady rush of buying something beautiful for one's self made resisting temptation nigh impossible. And that is probably a rather unhealthy attitude to have.What an interesting read this thread has been, thank you @blydia for starting it! I've enjoyed seeing so many perspectives on this subject.
I took a precipitous fall down the orange slide - it has been beautiful slide, but expensive. I've made a few mistakes, and re-homed most of them. Some I've kept because I'm still on the fence about them, or I don't mind wearing them for walking the dog, gardening or just keeping me warm when I don't feel like dressing up - who knew they'd look so great with comfy clothes?
I look at them as art, wearable art. And like art for your home, it is a personal expense, one that you take on knowing not everyone will understand or appreciate. They are mine to do with what I will - I made a tote bag out of two of them - even if that is to sit in a drawer till I wear it next. When I look in the drawers, they are neatly laid out by color, nicely folded, and if I listen closely, they are all saying "Me! Me! Me today!"
There is a CPW, but I look more at the PPW (pleasure per wear) - because they are a pleasure. My DH has things he enjoys (golf and wine), and I have mine. He rarely comments on the scarves - though I do get the feeling he hopes I'm slowing down - but he does notice them. I do occasionally feel a little guilty about a purchase - it's not like I *need* them - but I have only once paid more than what a scarf originally cost in the boutiques. That once was for a grail... after I paid an astronomical price for it, I found it two weeks later for less than $100. <face palm> So I bought that one too, averaged the cost together, and now I don't feel so bad about it - I refer to this process as "H Maths".
I've kept a spreadsheet for 3 years, and I've used the Stylebook app for 2 years. This week - to the best of my abilities due to missing information - I added the CPW to the spreadsheet, for curiosity's sake. It wasn't particularly eye-opening - like @bunnycat, I pretty much know what's getting worn and what's not. Plus the newer additions (FW 2019 killed my wallet - I held a small, private ceremony in the backyard) look terrible compared to many of the older scarves… some are practically free now! Which is a very good thing.
Thanks for listening!
But what put the kibosh on scarf buying for me was 4 things: finances, life style change, change in SA, and H's color family concept/simplification of designs. Finances: in the early collecting stage I did go over my budget and did not save as I should. For insurance purposes I started a speadsheet of all H goodies, and between scarves and exotic CDCs, I spent the equivalent of a downpayment on a home. Very scary and eye opening. I also started an MBA four years ago and H monies became tuition monies. My SA left around the same time and I don't have quite the rapport with my new one as I did my old one. With working full time and going to school in the evenings, I dress casually and have little to no time for grabbing and coordinating a scarf, so all my beauties have been languishing unworn. Once school finishes, I do anticipate returning to enjoying my collection.
Finally, the biggest impact on my buying has been the H color family concept and the simple/dull/mashup designs of the last few seasons put a nail in the scarf buying coffin. I get 1-2 a season at most and to be honest, the last three that I have bought, are still in the boxes unworn. I am more focused on the back catalog and to find some of them, it is a long game that requires patience and persistence.