I am a little confused. These are the same bracelet and you are just wondering if it is still a nice color when next to your skin as well as when it is held away from your skin in the light? If so, I do like both shades.
In my opinion these are two very good shades, but it really comes down to your personal preference.
I had 2 bracelets sent to me to check the color in person, but neither one matched my necklace, unfortunately. I need the shade of your bracelet to match, so let me know if you do decide to return this one (I think we shop at the same boutique).
I think I would keep it if I were you, but maybe ask your SA to send you a second one to compare it with first so that you can be sure.