My vote is for the violet. I'm neither a purple nor pink girl, but the leather on your violet is TDF!! Plus, I love darker, richer colors, which the violet definitely is. I'm not crazy about rose though, and the one you're considering looks very broken in already. For me, I love a broken in bbag, but I realize I want to be the one to break it in. My bordeaux came to me already broken-in, and it kinda bugs me for some reason. I don't get that same satisfaction out of the bag.
alaska, you mention that the jaune clutch is nice but your really want it in vert thyme. why don't you sell that one, get the rose, and then when the cash come up, get the vt? my 2 cents!
Dilemma....I am in crisis for you ..I love Violet...but rose twiggy..:shame:
Keep the Violet - sell the Clutch if you have to!
^ good advice! And u can look around the house for a couple of other items to sell off instead of the violet! If I had to choose, I'd keep the violet...you broke her in and u have a relationship w/her.... no matter how rare and gorgeous a bbag from the past it, it is still a used purse...just my humble opinion... I had my HG in my hands before, but it was not new and that bothered me esp. considering the price I paid...I was afraid to wear her out more and so I sold her off rather quickly! I love rose but ur VIOLET city, that's one special bbag...!
I'd keep the violet only because I don't care for the Twiggy style personally.
Alaska, it sounds like your Violet means a lot to you... we all have one bag that holds a special place in our as corny as it sounds.. . If the rose twiggy wasn't a HG to begin with.. I'd pass on it, even if it has gorgeous leather. When you put the violet away & pull it back out later to use.. you'll fall in love all over again. gOod luck~!
This was hard to vote on because it sounds like you really love your Violet. Since I had only 2 choices I voted rose for this reason. Violets will be popping up ion Ebay fairly often for quite a while. A Rose in good condition is much harder to find and it's so beautiful and it has tassels to fiddle with when you're bored.
I would keep the violet - I'd be way too scared of getting the pink dirty, plus I love a darker shade color.
I really love the violet so I voted to keep it!