PLS HELP!! which leather jacket should i keep?

you're not alone :P I vote for the RO also. and I KNOW jackets are SUPPOSED to fit like that Black one, but I would have to size up also :shame:
I just cannot wear them like that :shrugs:

Whew! I'm with queen and paper on liking the RO in appearance. Soo pretty!

However, in your most recent post, you said if you wore it over an hour, the underarm area starts to feel uncomfortable makes me want to vote for the black for comfort.