Controversial opinion, but I sort of agree. The Purseforum audience definitely is willing to pay for the real deal, but I think we also generally agree that luxury houses nowadays are really in it for the cash grab. The Puzzle Edge being pushed so heavily is 100% a symptom of lower quality but higher prices. If you're going to sell a really good replica with good leather and craftsmanship, just price it fairly and say that it's a replica! The scamming is so unnecessary.Fakes are crazy these days! I had posted here about a Otori-Sama wallet on Fashionphile I was interested in but was suspicious. I pulled the trigger anyways because I had the option for free return and it was so obviously a fake. But it was INSANELY well made. The marquetry, dimensions, etc. was identical. What clued me into it was the thickness of the leather, the smell and the feel of it in hand. Another clue specifically for this wallet was that 4-5 other listings had the wallet with the same control # and identical photos. Otherwise it was honestly impossible to tell from photos.
Ethics aside, I'm not totally against fakes/replicas in general considering the ridiculous prices of the luxury market now. Instead, I'm really against people selling fakes as if they're real. If you're gonna sell me a fake give it to me for $50, don't try to trick me 😂
But clearly the scammers get away with it often enough that making that insane profit is worth a few extremely irate customers.