Now if only they made an LV black multi speedy 25 with black handles and no heavy hardware <sigh>. Ok back to reality...there has been quite a bit of discussion about rolled handles being better. I like rolled handles better to carry in my hand, however, I like the flat handles of the Audrey to carry on my wrist or crook of the arm. I find with rolled handles my wrist/arm gets red marks easier and feels heavier after awhile.
If a rolled handled satchel is desirable to you, I would try buying a Sabrina off ebay or bonanza. My steel Sabrina goes with everything. I have debated long and hard about buying an LV, however I wear a lot of shirts with patterns on them rather than solids. I think an LV might look too busy or clash with my things.
Being that you are a shoulder bag girl and want to add a satchel round out your collection, I would go for the less expensive option the Audrey. If you get more use out of shoulder bags, then an LV in a shoulder style would be a better investment. I would hate to drop that much money on a satchel that may not get much use.