Keep or exchange for Lindsay

[Lisa Lisa]

I purchased this Saddle Peyton during PCE and I am not really feeling this bag even though it is a Limited Edition. Opinions? Keep or should I exchange for the Lindsay which isn't available until September. TIA!

 

[luralee]

I said return and get a diff color Peyton. Love the Peyton, but think the bag is not a "saddle" color bag. Sounds weird I know, but JMHO.

 

[beautyinside]

You should never keep a bag that you don't love...unless you plan to sell it. So, I think you should exchange it, and hopefully you'll like the other bag better. Good luck!

 

[gypsumrose]

If you think you'll like Lindsay more, limited edition aside, I think you have a winner!

 

[jen6292]

I say to try it in another color, and if you are still not feeling it then I would exchange it! JMO

 

[mary G]

I love the lindsay in gray I keep calling Jax about it and it will be avail mid sept. That said lindsay in grey! that gets my vote!

 

[nutz4purses]

WELL, I voted Gray Lindsay because I am wanting this bag myself, I love the Lindsay!!! Best of Luck!!!

 

[kphillips]

Lindsay! Not digging the Peyton at all.

 

[selketkrb]

I am going to have to vote for Lindsay as well. Good luck!

 

[babidius]

get another Peyton!

 

[karester]

I say the Lindsay!

 

[jeh3v]

I just really love the Peyton, so I voted to exchange it for another color Peyton. I just think it's so much more beautiful in the other shades it's offered in, even if this one is Limited edition. Good luck deciding!

 

[nawth21]

I looooooooove my teal Lindsay. The shape, color and size are perfect for me. I do like the pink peyton but I dont love the shape.

 

[baglady39]

I voted to get the Peyton in another color. While I like the Lindsay, I find it a bit squatty and prefer the Peyton overall...as well as the colors. I also saw the saddle color at the boutique, and while I liked it IRL, it didn't "wow" me. I think the colors are so much more beautiful, and at least this is a bag that Coach is actually making in some different colors! Of course, if you don't like color and prefer a more neutral bag, then probably the gray Lindsay would be best. You really can't go wrong with any of the choices!! Good luck with your decision!!

 

[Charlie]

I voted for Grey Lindsay as well, this is one hot bag!