Keep or exchange for Lindsay

Saddle Peyton or Gray Lindsay

  • Keep Saddle Peyton

  • Return Saddle Peyton and get another color Peyton

  • Return Saddle Peyton for Gray Lindsay

  • Return Saddle Peyton for another color Lindsay


Results are only viewable after voting.

Lisa Lisa

O.G.
Jun 6, 2007
1,015
0
Oviedo, Florida
I purchased this Saddle Peyton during PCE and I am not really feeling this bag even though it is a Limited Edition. Opinions? Keep or should I exchange for the Lindsay which isn't available until September. TIA! :nuts:
 

Attachments

luralee

Changes mind always!
O.G.
Aug 25, 2007
2,263
9
VR, MO
I said return and get a diff color Peyton. Love the Peyton, but think the bag is not a "saddle" color bag. Sounds weird I know, but JMHO.
 

beautyinside

Nail Polish Fiend
Sep 2, 2006
655
0
Canada
You should never keep a bag that you don't love...unless you plan to sell it. So, I think you should exchange it, and hopefully you'll like the other bag better. Good luck!
 

gypsumrose

Bella Enchanted
O.G.
Oct 4, 2007
3,086
223
IL
If you think you'll like Lindsay more, limited edition aside, I think you have a winner!
 

jen6292

Member
Feb 4, 2008
2,221
0
OR
I say to try it in another color, and if you are still not feeling it then I would exchange it!:tup: JMO
 

mary G

Member
Oct 14, 2007
1,688
0
Midwest
I love the lindsay in gray I keep calling Jax about it and it will be avail mid sept. That said lindsay in grey! that gets my vote!
 
Aug 2, 2006
2,831
1
WELL, I voted Gray Lindsay because I am wanting this bag myself, I love the Lindsay!!! Best of Luck!!!
 

jeh3v

RM Love
O.G.
Jun 5, 2008
15,732
3
Nashville, TN
I just really love the Peyton, so I voted to exchange it for another color Peyton. I just think it's so much more beautiful in the other shades it's offered in, even if this one is Limited edition. Good luck deciding!
 

nawth21

Addicted!
O.G.
Feb 21, 2006
3,697
1
38
Twin Cities MN
I looooooooove my teal Lindsay. The shape, color and size are perfect for me. I do like the pink peyton but I dont love the shape.
 

baglady39

L E G A C Y
O.G.
Sep 15, 2007
11,944
7
I voted to get the Peyton in another color. While I like the Lindsay, I find it a bit squatty and prefer the Peyton overall...as well as the colors. I also saw the saddle color at the boutique, and while I liked it IRL, it didn't "wow" me. I think the colors are so much more beautiful, and at least this is a bag that Coach is actually making in some different colors! Of course, if you don't like color and prefer a more neutral bag, then probably the gray Lindsay would be best. You really can't go wrong with any of the choices!! Good luck with your decision!!