I wanted to say one more thing I want the grey Lindsay also but the coach website now say avail. 11/2 and nordies has it backordered until 11/7 on there website. man 2 more months of waiting I dont know if I can wait that long!
I voted to get the Peyton in another color. While I like the Lindsay, I find it a bit squatty and prefer the Peyton overall...as well as the colors. I also saw the saddle color at the boutique, and while I liked it IRL, it didn't "wow" me. I think the colors are so much more beautiful, and at least this is a bag that Coach is actually making in some different colors! Of course, if you don't like color and prefer a more neutral bag, then probably the gray Lindsay would be best. You really can't go wrong with any of the choices!! Good luck with your decision!!
I've been lurking here for awhile and am LOVING IT. I got a Lindsay in espresso and a Peyton in saddle. I hear you on the Peyton...not loving the color or the bag in general. I don't think I have heard anyone comment on the size. I love a big bag, but felt that was more "luggage like". Maybe it is the width. I returned the Peyton and got the Hamptons Vintage Hobo, am still debating on that. I LOVE my Lindsay, have gotten so many compliments! I would vote for the Lindsay. I am considering another in the gray myself!
Which colr of lindsay? I backordered the gray it should be in the warehouse the end of next week to ship out!