Excuse-me for bumping this thread. Though I had bought one some years ago. Both, the "foldable compact" one as well as the classic "long version" are both very well made. Though IMO both are really very heavy.
I decided on the foldable one, since the classic one did not come with a "sleeve". (I do not like leaving such an umbrella at the door, nor take it dripping through a boutique/restaurant. The foldable one does not have an "automatic" opening (if I recall correctly neither did the other), so I had to use both hands to open it. This and the really heavy weight made me gift it to a male family member (who then "lost it" having left it at the entrance of a nice boutique...). Hope that helps. If you don't mind the weight - beautiful umbrellas.