Help, I need advice on an eBay return process for a refund.
The quick story is this:
I bought a 1.3K Hermes watch from a trusted seller whom I've happily purchased (H scarves) many times from for over a year. Watch arrived, not as described, very worn, scratched, not new, even watch band was different than was in auction photos. I contacted seller, sent pics, seller kindly apologized for the mistake and offered a refund after I return the item. I said OK, will return it, insure it, send it on Monday.
Here's the catch: I'm in the US - returning item to the UK and I want to insure it for full value to protect myself. But seller has now emailed me back and asked me to declare the item as a gift of only $40 value!
If I don't do as they say, will I anger them, causing a problem for my refund? If I do as they ask, that's dishonest and probably illegal. I assume it will cost them some $ or possibly flag them as a commercial operation if I declare the full value. Do I have this correct, or can someone further explain the issue with customs here?
How is the BEST way to handle this? All input will be greatly appreciated!