I called just yesterday about a bag that I wanted to return. It was a white bag that was redyed. The leather in the straps was a dingy gray/used and the bag leather was a perfect clean non-matching stiff white and was already cracking from the dryness of being redyed. I understand your upset for sure! They did take mine back but I spend a lot of $$$$$ there so maybe that is why? Do you have a history of big purchases, because I think that helped me a bit. She was reluctant at first but I directed her to my purchase history and she was fine with it, then. I had ordered another 3 bags the previous week and they were fine. It is hit and miss, I think. More miss, lol.