Definitely on the right track! I've noticed that Ben Gay (menthol?) smell too. It seems to go away once the bag is dry.View attachment 3748067 View attachment 3748051 Ok, y'all...reading back through posts trying to learn. This brown city bag I am working on..... I went about things backwards, being the newbie that I am. I did Leather CPR and Blackrock first. Then I dunked it. When I dunked it, the water came out the color if iced tea. After a soak in cool water and dawn, I rinsed it and let it soak in plain water. The water was a very weak tea color this time. I stuffed it with towels. This morning I put on a coat of Leather CPR. It looks much better, but it smells of Ben Gay muscle rub.
On the right track?
This is the before photo, it is much darker right now, perhaps because it is still damp. I don't mind, as long as it looks nice.
Buffing the bag with a horsehair brush or microfiber cloth about 8 hours after each coat of conditioner really helps work the conditioner in too.