I would like to buy this bag for my mom but I have no experience with the Madison line. For those of you here that own bags from this line, do you find the caviar leather to be as durable and forgiving as the glove tanned leather? Do these bags feel well made and luxurious? Can the hardware be polished and minor scratches and stains rubbed out, similarly to the glove tanned leather? I've seen beautiful rehabs of these bags but I'm a little scared of them, they look delicate to me. I gave my mom one of the NYC convertible clutches that I rehabbed and she liked it a lot more than I thought she would have (or so she said...with moms you never know when they're being honest or when they're being a mom supporting her daughter's odd hobby). I want to give her an Italian made bag. I think she would love that. What do you ladies think about these bags in terms of durability?
https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https://www.ebay.com/ulk/itm/264607411513
That is the Coach Royalton 4403 in Beechnut, I have that bag and I think it is lovely. I like the vintage Madison bags, they are structured and ladylike and they remind me of Audrey Hepburn or Grace Kelly. They are not for everybody because they are old-fashioned but they just feel finely-crafted, luxurious, and special - to me anyway!
The creed patch on the Italian Madison bags state that they are hand-made and "specially treated to maintain a new appearance over time" and they do! The leather on these Italian Madison bags is very unusual and not everyone likes it because it is shiny and a bit slick.
It is a pebbled leather that that has light/dark coloration. Coach called it "caviar leather." A Cobbler once told me that the tiny dark spots that appear on the top of each "bump" is actually printed on RHW leather. He said that it is very expensive process and difficult to do. (I have no idea what "RHW leather" means, but I have seen that term used with some Chanel bags.
IMO they are not delicate although they have that reputation. I have dunked them and put them through the full rehab treatment and they all come out just fine - but they take forever to dry!
You can polish the hardware, but if you polish heavily it may lose the brushed gold appearance and become shiny gold. If the leather looks dull in areas after cleaning then sometimes Lexol or Leather Therapy Restorer & Conditioner can bring back the shine.
Below are some pics of my Beechnut Royalton including some shots next to Gracie so you can see the size difference. They are old photos and not the most clear pics but maybe you can get the idea. the Gracie is very small and the Royalton is a bit larger.
And here are links to 2 Italian Madison rehabs that I recently completed, including dunking them both, a cherry red Carlyle and a forest green Drake:
Carlyle Before:
https://forum.purseblog.com/threads/coach-rehab-and-rescue-club.833400/page-1646#post-33532703
Carlyle After:
https://forum.purseblog.com/threads/coach-rehab-and-rescue-club.833400/page-1646#post-33532733
Drake Before:
https://forum.purseblog.com/threads/coach-rehab-and-rescue-club.833400/page-1646#post-33532798
Drake After:
https://forum.purseblog.com/threads/coach-rehab-and-rescue-club.833400/page-1646#post-33532882
View attachment 4649637
View attachment 4649639
View attachment 4649640
View attachment 4649641
View attachment 4649642
View attachment 4649650
@Morgan_Bellini I found a picture of my beechnut royalton next to my black Carlyle and beechnut gracie, again to give you an idea of size - none of these are big bags, but the royalton is the largest of the 3.
