I've rehabbed several of the Italian
Coach bags including the Carlyle. Most of them have just needed surface cleaning but I have dunked a few of them and they came out well, but they need a long time to dry. I don't use a creamy conditioner on them, I use "leather therapy restorer & conditioner" to condition and restore the shine.
Here's a picture of my first Italian Coach bag, the tiny Gracie bag in Beechnut color. I picked it up for only $2 at the Salvation Army Store. It was missing the strap so I use a Coach gold chain strap.
https://forum.purseblog.com/threads...-carrying-today.913052/page-940#post-32544542
The shiny, pebbled leather is called "Caviar Leather" and it is very fine and difficult to make. These Italian Coach bags were originally made by Coach in imitation of the Hermes Kelly bag.
Here are pics of a recent acquisition, a small Coach bag that was hand-made in Italy in 2000. It is a limited-edition, numbered bag that is made from genuine Lizard with suede pigskin lining. I just surface-cleaned it and used reptile leather conditioner.
https://forum.purseblog.com/threads...-hand-made-and-vintage.1017506/#post-33338212
I like the Italian coach bags from the mid/late 1990s, they are very well made and they always make me think of Audrey Hepburn and Grace Kelly, but it is not a style that appeals to everyone.