I think some people put shoe polish on even if it doesn't need it, especially if the bag is white or black. Hopefully, it will be fine once you get the polish off. Black bags don't usually show stains.I decided to dunk it....I'm guessing it was a good choice since the water turned black immediately. Not gray - deep, dark black...and my hands are even black just from dunking. She's soaking....I'm a little scared to find what's under all that polish. Other than to cover something up why would someone do that to a perfectly good purse?