I ONLY carry vintage Coach bags. I strongly prefer the older leather. I also carry vintage Fossil (the vintage pebbled leather is TDF), vintage Furla, and thrifted or ebay'd older Francesco Biasia. My only new (as opposed to new-to-me) bags are my Perla European style briefcase given to me for 10 years at my job, and a red Frye Brooke small satchel I just got. I LOVE the Frye satchel, and if you like the feel of older USA made Coach, Frye might appeal to you. It is also made in the US, and the leather is quite similar to older Coach leather - thick and soft. Stylistically they are different, but if you like the styles they will probably appeal to you quality-wise.