I wwear purse charms on most of my bags... I make them.
So I'm a bit biased towards the look.
I think if you like what you're doing, then go for it.

I think if you like what you're doing, then go for it.

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
^^^Cute, caxe! Congrats on your big news, btw.
OP, I think scarves on bags can look really nice, and I agree that you should follow your own sense of style and do what you like. There are plenty of jerks in the world and you'll never please them all. And who would want to anyway?
I think that scarf could complement that bag very well. Maybe you should experiment with some different ways of tying it. For example, you could fold it a few times lengthwise to make it more like a bandeau before you tie it on. To me, it is a little overpowering to the bag the way it's tied now. But if you like it spread out, then keep it that way.
Piss on 'em. LOL