That's what I mentioned earlier~ this bag was released for Fall and the fake I have does not have that on the back of the hangtag like mine did. It is a good fake, which is why I bought it in the first place. But I was sooooooooo disappointed to find out it was fake when it arrived. I am curious about one thing though BB~ how are you able to tell the exact month the bag was made?
Also, I apologize if I got a little annoying with my questioning~ it's just very frustrating when you know you have a fake and someone says otherwise because they can't inspect it in person. In person I have no doubt at all you would know it is fake instantaneously simply because the suede and leather aren't genuine. I appreciate you reviewing the evidence as much as you did. When I get my authentic bag in blue I would like to submit a pic of the patent # on the snap~ I think it's a good thing to be aware of.
I have looked over the photos again and there are certain incorrect details on the bag that I just can't ignore.
The magnetic snap is one of the major things about this bag that concerns me. I realize that Coach isn't always consistent regarding hardware, however, there are a few things that Coach IS consistent about and the magnetic snap is one of them. This is one of the things that I insist on seeing when I look at an item that has one. (Screws are another.) ALL of the magnetic snaps I have seen on authentic items (and I have seen many on many Coach items, not just bags) have always been consistent. I have also seen magnetic snaps on fakes and the fake magnetic snaps have looked similar to the snap in the picture, with other lettering and wording.
The feet on the bottom of the OP's bag is another detail that is blatantly incorrect. This is another detail that I ask to see on a bag. I have seen fakes with "correct" looking feet, but the feet on the OP's bag are completely wrong. This is the type of feet I've seen on fakes.
The problem is that we can no longer expect the fake factories to always churn out shotty replicas we can determine easily. Sometimes they take more care and make them almost just like the originals and that's a big problem.
A link was posted here awhile ago to a replica site that was selling extremely realistic-looking designer items. We had a discussion about whether the pictures on the site showed the actual items. They did use a Coach stock photo for the first picture, however, they claimed that the other pictures were pictures of the actual items. Some of us looked at the pictures and for some of the bags, it was virtually impossible to tell from the pictures whether they were pictures of a fake or real bag. The site advertised these replicas as better than Grade A quality and the prices for individual items were more expensive than outlet and retail sale prices (probably because the items are meant to be wholesaled). If the pictures show the actual replicas, these are some of the scariest fakes I've ever seen.
Another major issue is the dissolution of the Coach authentication department. I am wondering if you guys have heard of this happening recently? All I know about it is I received a letter along with my bag back in the mail. I will try to find it~ maybe it says something I missed but it's not a good thing for us ebayers.
According to this thread, Coach has discontinued the authentication service:
http://forum.purseblog.com/ebay-forum/buy-a-bag-ebay-etc-coach-will-authenticate-581932.html
OP, after looking at all your pictures and reading your description of the bag and comparing the pictures to authentic ones of this style, it is my belief that you got a fake. The bag is a very well-made fake, but as with other realistic-looking fakes we've seen before, there are certain details that are wrong.
It's always a risk when you buy from somewhere other than an authorized retailer. In this case, you bought from a seller who bought it from someone else on ebay. The original source cannot be determined.
I hope this situation can come to a satisfactory conclusion for both you and the seller because both of you were duped.