I have the petite albion ring in lemon citrine (wearing it today, actually). I got it two years ago from a local jeweler. I would not have bought it if I felt the quality was poor. I have a few other DY pieces, and I haven't been disappointed with them, although the bracelet I have with a pave diamond "X" on it is slightly chipped on the "X" part (because of my clumsiness, I'm sure). Haven't gotten around it looking into fixing it. Having said all this, I haven't tried any DY jewelry on recently, so I don't know about the quality today vs. a few years ago.