Anyone Ever Buy and/or Sell on Tradesy?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I emailed Tradesy back and forth about Fedex after their initial announcement about carrier change and specifically asked them to make it up to the seller to choose USPS or Fedex. they said they would forward it further and it looks like they've listened.
Though I'm not selling with them again after another return went horribly wrong (allegedly buyer returned expensive Dior bag but it never showed up, 1 month later and I had to fight to get my funds via BBB).
Now it would be great if Tradesy makes it up to the seller to decide to accept returns or not. Like we can click "accept returns" on and off for each listing.
I'm so sorry about your horrible return. It sounds like you got your funds, which is good. I'm not making a lot of sales, and I hold my breath with each, hoping there isn't going to be a return. So far, so good. I don't sell anything I can't afford to lose. If the package gets lost, it's not a big deal financially.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GemsBerry
Though I'm not selling with them again after another return went horribly wrong (allegedly buyer returned expensive Dior bag but it never showed up, 1 month later I had to fight to get my funds via BBB).
Now it would be great if Tradesy makes it up to the seller to decide to accept returns or not. Like we can click "accept returns" on and off for each listing.

oh no!! did FedEx lose the parcel during transit or the buyer never returned? either way I agree that you shouldn't have had to fight to claim your funds back. lost parcels would've been covered by their insurance policy, and if the buyer never returned it then no refund to her.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GemsBerry
oh no!! did FedEx lose the parcel during transit or the buyer never returned? either way I agree that you shouldn't have had to fight to claim your funds back. lost parcels would've been covered by their insurance policy, and if the buyer never returned it then no refund to her.
It was back then when only USPS was used over 1.5 months ago. Apparently, buyer's return was lost. Timeline: I got sale, Tradesy requested additional pics and authenticated the bag on the same day, I shipped the next day. it was delivered on 7th day. then buyer allegedly returned. however, her return never reached Tradesy, nobody provided me tracking and Tradesy kept telling me "to wait" for a month.
Honestly, I'm not sure about the whole return thing. maybe she never shipped it or she doesn't know how to attach label and tape the package correctly and something happened. I got paid bec I made a huge stink one month later:smile:
 
It was back then when only USPS was used over 1.5 months ago. Apparently, buyer's return was lost. Timeline: I got sale, Tradesy requested additional pics and authenticated the bag on the same day, I shipped the next day. it was delivered on 7th day. then buyer allegedly returned. however, her return never reached Tradesy, nobody provided me tracking and Tradesy kept telling me "to wait" for a month.
Honestly, I'm not sure about the whole return thing. maybe she never shipped it or she doesn't know how to attach label and tape the package correctly and something happened. I got paid bec I made a huge stink one month later:smile:
believe you me ppl learned quick how to attach label to box when they want their refund!! Amazon has trained them well. instead my money is on your buyer attempting to scam you and never posted her return. even at its worst time, USPS tracking always shows the current location where the parcel last scanned, and when it got stuck in the mail depot like mine did for 3 weeks, Tradesy and my buyer always knew where it was.

yeah they shouldn't have debited your account BEFORE the return arrived in their office. glad though it worked out for you in the end, painful I know....
 
  • Like
Reactions: GemsBerry
Lightning fast! I requested a paypal transfer on Saturday 3/20, it got there on Monday 3/22. When I initiated it, I believe it said 4 or 5 days, which is much quicker than before.
 
believe you me ppl learned quick how to attach label to box when they want their refund!! Amazon has trained them well. instead my money is on your buyer attempting to scam you and never posted her return. even at its worst time, USPS tracking always shows the current location where the parcel last scanned, and when it got stuck in the mail depot like mine did for 3 weeks, Tradesy and my buyer always knew where it was.

yeah they shouldn't have debited your account BEFORE the return arrived in their office. glad though it worked out for you in the end, painful I know....
I imagine her sale money was never released so they didn't have to debit her account. They just never gave her access to it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GemsBerry
I listed a few things:
my MIL's vintage 70's Fendi with attached Bergdorf tag, (she kept all her price tickets) was removed b/c they couldn't authenticate it. they asked for more pix then never responded.
sold a bottle of T Ford perfume I couldn't sell on Poshmark, a bit too long to xfer money to me I think

will probably remove my other listings
 
I have had a Poshmark account for several years and never sold 1 thing. Got 2 low ball offers and that was it. I don't even bother checking it anymore. Tradesy has had sales but very slow and very few. A handful in a maybe a half year. Mercari is impossible. They keep asking for debit and credit cards and then won't accept them and you can't list unless you jump through all their hoops - suddenly after having already listed 200 items and making 20 sales - they started this credit card nonsense. I even snail mailed a letter to their corporate office saying this is stupid - I don't leave a credit card on file anywhere and you already have my paypal info. No response. I would never give Ebay personal info like social or bank so I stopped selling there a year ago. I am really at a loss where a good platform is.
I don't like Mercari for the credit card on file reason as well, not leaving my Amex hanging out there,
Poshmark is where I am selling, it can work but its time intensive, but once you figure it out it's good.
 
I listed a few things:
my MIL's vintage 70's Fendi with attached Bergdorf tag, (she kept all her price tickets) was removed b/c they couldn't authenticate it. they asked for more pix then never responded.
sold a bottle of T Ford perfume I couldn't sell on Poshmark, a bit too long to xfer money to me I think

will probably remove my other listings
Can't you sell perfume on Posh? I didn't know Tradesy would remove items like that unless someone reported it. I thought that unless the buyer asked, they never looked at items with regards to authentication.
I don't like Mercari for the credit card on file reason as well, not leaving my Amex hanging out there,
Poshmark is where I am selling, it can work but its time intensive, but once you figure it out it's good.
I figure once I get one of those gift credit cards with a low limit, I can use it for Mercari. I wonder if it would still work once the credit was used up.
 
Can't you sell perfume on Posh? I didn't know Tradesy would remove items like that unless someone reported it. I thought that unless the buyer asked, they never looked at items with regards to authentication.

I figure once I get one of those gift credit cards with a low limit, I can use it for Mercari. I wonder if it would still work once the credit was used up.
Perfume isn't allowed as on Poshmark, something to do with shipping methods, too bad b/c they'd sell tons of it.
maybe some other buyer or seller didn't like my Fendi bag listing?
 
  • Like
Reactions: whateve
one of the recent articles explains what's going on https://finance.yahoo.com/news/tradesy-looks-next-big-thing-050119531.html
so Tradesy was investing in AI that "authenticates" by pictures. That would be good if it's working. But it doesn't.
It explains why my mailbox was spammed with "action required" emails demanding additional pics with codes while all of them were already posted (including "codes" for Tory Burch, really?). Even 1 item was removed. I emailed them with auth record and also asked for a screenshot of my listing where the required pics were "missing" bec they were not. they ignored it. fine with me, I'm not selling my luxury items with them anymore. their loss, their competitors' gain. keep mismanaging Tradesy. CS got even more horrible from horrible in the past, just bunch of employees hitting "piss off button #1" and "piss off #2" without looking at anything at all. Now it's non-working AI on top of that.
of course, they "don't disclose their profitability" bec they are not profitable. I hope someone will acquire them soon and I will reactivate my account.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gennas and ladyglen
one of the recent articles explains what's going on https://finance.yahoo.com/news/tradesy-looks-next-big-thing-050119531.html
so Tradesy was investing in AI that "authenticates" by pictures. That would be good if it's working. But it doesn't.
It explains why my mailbox was spammed with "action required" emails demanding additional pics with codes while all of them were already posted (including "codes" for Tory Burch, really?). Even 1 item was removed. I emailed them with auth record and also asked for a screenshot of my listing where the required pics were "missing" bec they were not. they ignored it. fine with me, I'm not selling my luxury items with them anymore. their loss, their competitors' gain. keep mismanaging Tradesy. CS got even more horrible from horrible in the past, just bunch of employees hitting "piss off button #1" and "piss off #2" without looking at anything at all. Now it's non-working AI on top of that.
of course, they "don't disclose their profitability" bec they are not profitable. I hope someone will acquire them soon and I will reactivate my account.
exactly what happened with my vintage Fendi
thanks for that update,
 
  • Like
Reactions: GemsBerry
one of the recent articles explains what's going on https://finance.yahoo.com/news/tradesy-looks-next-big-thing-050119531.html
so Tradesy was investing in AI that "authenticates" by pictures. That would be good if it's working. But it doesn't.
It explains why my mailbox was spammed with "action required" emails demanding additional pics with codes while all of them were already posted (including "codes" for Tory Burch, really?). Even 1 item was removed. I emailed them with auth record and also asked for a screenshot of my listing where the required pics were "missing" bec they were not. they ignored it. fine with me, I'm not selling my luxury items with them anymore. their loss, their competitors' gain. keep mismanaging Tradesy. CS got even more horrible from horrible in the past, just bunch of employees hitting "piss off button #1" and "piss off #2" without looking at anything at all. Now it's non-working AI on top of that.
of course, they "don't disclose their profitability" bec they are not profitable. I hope someone will acquire them soon and I will reactivate my account.
I wondered why I was asked for extra pictures. They expected creed pictures for Coach wristlets, most of which don't have creeds. I uploaded photos of the made in tag. I wonder if they will question them if they ever sell. The AI obviously doesn't work. You can upload a picture of any creed, doesn't have to be the one that is supposed to go with your bag, and they wouldn't catch it.
 
Top